Steadcast
Tides of History cover art
Tides of History

Popular History and Academic History

March 19, 202633 min · 6,379 words

Show notes

Academic history and popular history are very different things, but what is their purpose? And how should we, as people who like and consume history, understand and use them? Patrick launched a brand-new history show! It’s called Past Lives, and every episode explores the life of a real person who lived in the past.

Highlighted moments

I was taught to distrust narrative. The act of putting events in some sort of order, of picking and choosing what to emphasize and what not to, in service of a broader story, was anathema.
Something my dad said early in that process was that he read popular history for the story. That was totally foreign to me at the time.
It's not an image of trenches, a massed infantry attack being scythed down by machine gun fire, or Gavrilo Princip's assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand. It's the funeral, the cavalcade of gold braid and plumed helmets four years before a single shot was fired.
I have a distinct memory of my dissertation advisor telling me not to write something like this too well, lest readers think I'm trying to cover up substandard argumentation.

Transcript

Transcript not available for this episode yet.

More from Tides of History

Listen Now: Dan Taberski’s Manifesto

Jul 13, 20268 min

New Season - Dr. Death: The Cowboy

Jun 4, 20266 min

Listen Now: OnlyFantasy

May 21, 20267 min

The End

Apr 30, 202636 min

Lewis and Clark, the Corps of Discovery, and Writing Collective History: Interview with Author Craig Fehrman

Apr 23, 202644 min