TWiT 1097: Gina and the Glueballs - Is AI Moving Too Fast?

Introducing the guests

0:00Oh, we got a great twit coming up for you. Hi, everybody. Leo Laporte here. Joining me this week, my old friend, Gina Smith. She and I wrote my first book way back when. Gina's back. She also got me on TV and a bunch of other stuff. She was at Dvorak's funeral. We'll talk about that. My also, my dear friend, Denise Howell is here, my internet attorney and accordion enthusiast and AI guru, Joey Davila. Lots to talk about AI watermarks. Is that a good thing or a bad thing? And Mark Zuckerberg says, let the AI be free, but can we trust him with it?

0:34All that and more coming up next on TWIT.

0:39Podcasts you love. From people you trust. This is TWIT.

0:50This is TWIT. This Week in Tech, episode 1097. Recorded Sunday, August 16th, 2026. Gina and the glue balls.

1:02It's time for TWIT. This Week in Tech, the show we cover the week's tech news. Say hello to my dear friend, Denise Howell. Great to see you, Denise. Her current podcast is hearsayculture.com. And you've had some very, very good guests on. I've had one of the best, being one Leo Laporte. It's great to be here. So nice to see you, Denise. I appreciate it. Also with us, Joey Davila. It's great to see you. Hey there, good to see you as well. Global. Globalnerdy.com. Good friend. Love the shirt. It's a camo Hawaii shirt, kind of.

1:39Actually, this is in Net Foundry Colors. Oh, all right. I'm flying the company flag today. Is that khaki white and black? White. Oh, blue, white. Blue, green. Blue, green, white. Blue, green, white. Love it. It's good to see you. And I want to welcome back to our microphones. She hasn't been here in a few years, but it's so good to see my dear friend, Gina Smith, who goes so far back. We go so far back. We hosted a radio show together for so many years. Yeah. After Dvorak on computers,

2:09when John took off, Gina took over. That was like 1991? 1991? Was that before we did the computer show? Well before. Two or three years before. On CNBC. And then we worked for Ziff Davis. Gina went on to fame. My first book I wrote with you, 101 Computer Answers You Need to Know, which was originally 1001 Computer Answers, but the publisher decided that was too many. I forgot that. Really? Were we going to do that? We were going to call it. The title you and I came up with is How to Get the Dog Hair Out of the Disc Drive.

2:44That's right. Cat hair. But yes, it was cat hair. And the publisher did not like that, named it 101 Computer Answers. And shortly after our book came out, and ours wasn't that thick. I have one over here I'll pull out. But Kim Commando wrote one that was 1001 Computer Answers You Need to Know, and it was this thick. Which do you think people bought? Yeah. Oh, this one's 10 times more answers. Well, we were all used to train AI. That's true. Actually, I did do this search, you know, when they were doing that. And a few of my books,

3:17not our book, but a few of my books were on that. A few of mine too. I wrote the Wozniak memoir. I was. You did I was. Yeah. And that was one of the first things that they sucked up. Did you get your $3,000? No, I'm waiting for it. You did. You applied. Oh, I totally applied. I think the publisher takes a cut. Yeah. Yeah. You did a book on genomics as well. Yeah. Also, well ahead of the curve. Very smart. Woz celebrated his, I think, 78th birthday last week. That's right. August 11th. Happy birthday, Woz.

3:48He was. He's a great guy. He's so nice. You know, my son still calls him Uncle Steve. Oh, wow. And nobody believes that he knows him. So his friends are constantly saying, does he really know him? Sure. I'm like, sure he does. I got, I got a, uh, a Woz souvenir. I'm, I'm not. Oh, is it the weird bracelets? Woz autographed it to my son. I still haven't given it to him, but maybe I'll give it to him. He gives me one of his sandwiches, which he still hasn't done. Remember Woz would walk around with $2 bills. I have rolls of those somewhere. He signed them, huh?

4:21Yeah. But it says to Henry, which kind of, now I have to say, I know Woz signed it because I was there. I'm thinking Henry wrote to Henry on that. Cause it kind of doesn't, I, I don't know. Gina, can you validate the two Henry? Does that Woz's handwriting? It does not look like his handwriting. I think Henry wrote that. The Woz signature definitely is. Oh, I know this is Woz. I saw him sign it. Oh, okay. Cause. We were on a cruise. We were going to Antarctica. It was the, it was a geek cruise, Mackie cruise.

4:53And we were going to Antarctica and we, we, we show up all in heavy, you know, outerwear cause we're going to the cold and, and the cruise director comes with a clipboard and the pilot comes with a clipboard. And they said, well, the weather is just too tough. We're not going to be able to go there. And then I said, well, have you, what? I paid for this. Have you ever gone there? He said, no, no, we've never been able to go there, but we always schedule this.

5:22We've never made it. We've never made it. We live in hope, but instead we're going to, and I can't remember the name of it, some beautiful mountain scenery. And all of us are sitting in this, you know, bus going to the national park in Chile is sweating in our, in our Antarctic overclothes. And was takes off his overclothes and he's wearing shorts and a Hawaiian shirt. Cause that's how he dresses. That's how he dresses. And he was very comfortable. And so we saw the scenery.

5:54I have a picture of him signing the $2 bills. So his whole gig with those $2 bills is that he gives them to you, but then he makes you swear that you'll go to Starbucks or something with them. And you have to like, let the whole roll fall and pull out scissors out of your pocket and cut and then give it to the vendor. And that was his requirement. He tries to get them to say it's counterfeit. Yeah. He does the whole point. He buys them from the treasury on cut. And he'll say things like, this is a official government money.

6:26He had this whole spiel that he would do. And he's, and his whole goal is cause he's such a prankster to get them to like call the feds, but it's real money. It's a, it's a real $2 bill. Oh, he really is. I don't know. I keep saying was we put, we put a prank in the was book. If you ever see it, we say the exact time on a digital clock that he figured out how to put a typewriter and a TV together with, you know, computer circuitry. And he says, yes, I looked at the digital clock. It was 12 45 33 on this day,

7:01but it was long before anybody could buy these digital clocks. He wasn't, we just made it up. Well, now it's no big, right now. Nobody would question it. Yeah. But if you ask AI, you can ask it exactly what time was the first personal computer put together. It'll give you this fake time that we put in as a joke. So it's now in the training. Yes. It's in the training. It's in the book. I think that's awesome. And he didn't, he didn't know that it was going to end up becoming part of an AI model. He just thought it was funny to put that in the book.

7:32We just thought it would be funny to put a joke in the book. It's in like right before the prank chapter. We thought that would get away. I love it. We have many. And if you two aren't reliable sources, I don't know who is. Well, I would never hallucinate or lie to you. Never. A trivia book. Somebody who wrote a trivia book did poison a couple of trivia, trivia facts, quote, quote facts in the book just to catch people using it in using it in their own

8:08material without attribution. And I think that happened. Oh, there's a tradition in map making to do that, you know? Oh, okay. No, I did not know that. They steal maps. And so in the map making, they'll put phony landmarks or phony towns. And then if somebody plagiarizes your map, you know it because the phony town will appear and you go, aha, that's actually an old map maker's trick. There's a name for it. I'm sure the chat room will trap streets. Thank you, Patrick Delahanty. He knew immediately. Well, there we go. Or paper towns.

8:39Paper towns. I'm going into the fake AI training business now. I think there's money in that. There actually might be money in that. That's a great idea. Please don't. Can I speak for all AI users? Please don't. That's not pollute the source of our information. No, no, I, no, I won't. Yeah. I'll just start spreading the rumor. You know, those things in raisin brand, they're not raisins. Yes. Birds aren't real. And then you complain that AI is hallucinating.

9:10It's your fault. But Leo, if you want to protect the AI quality, then you don't let private companies.

Mark Zuckerberg on open AI

9:18Well,

Mark Zuckerberg on open AI

9:19I'm all in on local AI. And that brings us to Mark Zuckerberg, 6,500 word post, which I tried. I tried to read, but I skimmed it. The future is for everyone. Yeah, because he wrote it with AI. I don't know. You know, it doesn't have any AI tells in it. And I'm getting pretty good at detecting those. Cause I talked to AI all the time. I couldn't. But that's the tell is that how long it is. But I do, I actually, and it hurts me to say this, but I agree with him. Me too. His whole premise is,

9:49as AI develops, the most important question we're going to deal with is, he says, the defining questions of our age are, who will have access to super intelligence? And what will we direct it towards? Will it be centralized and restricted to a few institutions? Or will it be a tool that empowers everyone? And really the whole piece is making the case for open weights, open models, not no one company controlling this, no one government controlling it.

10:20Although he says, you know, if you can trust government, it's not a bad idea for government to have some regulation on it. He believes everyone will have a personal super intelligent agent, smarter than a PhD. Forgive me, Gina.

10:35Smarter than a, than a lawyer. Forgive me, Denise. Both of you have higher degrees. And that this agent will be a really incredible, useful advisor. It'll be a tool for creation. It'll help people invent. And it all will happen if, and only if, it's free or affordable and widespread, he said, because the only way that we, we, we get something trustworthy and reliable is, is everybody can use it. And I don't,

11:06I don't disagree with that. Well, we've lived through this with the internet, right? I mean, in the beginning, it was going to lead to all kinds of political independence and the data was all going to be free and it wasn't going to be selling you anything. And now it's a big consumer. And you know why? Because Mark fricking Zuckerberg. He's part of it. Weaponized social media. Totally. And this is the only problem I have with this. And Mike Masnick put it beautifully in his detector post.

11:38Zuckerberg's right about open. Decentralized AI. He's also the last person you should trust to deliver it. Yeah. Well, yeah, he decentralized a good chunk of the web. Like, I mean, a lot of people just think Facebook is the web. That's where they go. As Nick says, it seems the only reason he's pushing this vision now is Meta's losing the AI race badly. But let's look at Zuckerberg's history. As soon as he can take control and centralize it, as he did with Facebook and then Instagram,

12:10he does. Well, this is true. I mean, this is exactly what he did. Two years ago, he came out and said, decentralized, decentralized. And then what did he do? He privatized it, right? The next model. And now he's saying decentralized because it's good for Meta. But Joey, it's good, right? Because Meta did release the first open weight models, Llama. It did. It was a perfect seed for open AI. Llama CPP was written. It became the engine that people use to run open models.

12:43Llama is based on Llama CPP. Then he stopped doing open models. And now he's released Glimmer, which is a really interesting, good local model. And it's promising to release Muse Spark, which he says is a frontier quality model. I haven't played. I played with Glimmer. These are open weight, not open source, though. Very important distinction. Yes.

13:06Right. And the overarching vision is what I come down to and go, do we really want to be there with this personal agent? That plays such an important role in people's lives. Do we really want to be there without a proper regulatory framework around what that looks like? And my answer to that is no. Well, and he raises that issue, but I also am very nervous about the Trump administration's attempts to regulate AI because I don't trust them. And I don't,

13:36maybe I don't shouldn't trust any government. On the other hand, that's the only way we as humans have a societal input. It needs to be regulated. I don't, I don't want these big companies with their vast monetization incentives to be in charge. Yeah. And if AI infrastructure really is that important to you, you know, do you want a company who's tied to quarterly results being the owner of that? I mean, it's nuts.

14:07I mean, we didn't put nuclear power in the hands of VCs. We certainly shouldn't put it in the hands of AI companies currently. So Zuckerberg's right, but it's in his, it's advantageous right now for him to say it. And will he turn his back on it? Like Joey was saying, can you trust him? No. Bruce Schneier actually published a very interesting editorial opinion piece in the Guardian. Yeah. That kind of addresses this. The whole idea of it is it's too big to be owned by individual companies.

14:39He says government should privatize open AI and Anthropic. Yeah. If, if they're not successful on the market, right. Isn't that what he said? Too big to fail kind of thing. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. If, yeah, it says if the markets, if the markets reject open AI and Anthropic, the U S should nationalize. And he wrote this with Nathan E Sanders.

15:05I don't know. That kind of makes me a little nervous. The nationalization word is a scary one, but you could picture this government saying communism. That's yeah. Yeah. But what are they doing with Intel? What are they doing? I mean, they are literally buying stakes and chip companies in exchange for keeping them afloat. people have pointed this out that while Trump got elected as a populist, for sure, representing the voice of the people, his constituency, it turns out is the very wealthy donors. We're giving him lots of money.

15:36So he has two masters, the people who voted for him, who don't want data centers, who don't, who don't want untrammeled AI. They may not want AI at all. And the people who funded him who are, Oh, surprise, building these giant data centers and creating these giant AIs. And, and his policy reflects that kind of duality because he has talked about regulating. And when he, when he got in office, the first thing he did is eliminate President Biden's AI regulation executive order.

16:09He said, no, no, we're not going to, we're not going to regulate. David Sachs is AI advisor said, no, no, no regulation at all. AI, if, if America is going to succeed, it has to be unregulated. It's the only way we can beat the Chinese at their own game. But now after Anthropic released mythos and fable, everybody got so scared. Trump actually pulled fable, rug pulled fable, said, you can't use it. Yeah. And the, and now it's talking about, well, we're going to have to have everybody submit their new models to us for,

16:4130 days before it's released to make sure it's safe, which on the surface, I don't think is a bad idea. Zuckerberg says 30 days and you're out of business in this, in this, in this rapidly evolving AI world, you have 30 days to make a model succeed. If you are holding it back, it's too late. Somebody's going to eclipse you. Maybe the Chinese. Yeah. I don't know. It's hurting people though. Right. I mean, you've got AI and a situation with their lawsuits around this.

17:14I mean, people are being harmed. Why wouldn't you regulate it? You've got Grok, what automatically nudifying.

17:21Yeah. I mean, somebody has got to regulate and protect people from this. And if it slows it down a little bit, is that bad? It's going so fast. Now, nobody can exert any governance over it to Denise's point, you know, looking at the governance. And I really want people with doctorate degrees in cognition fields like Gina to be taking a much closer look at the effects of when you have an AI tutor,

17:52you know, are you isolating children from a learning experience? Are you, are you turning off portions of their brain that are necessary for learning? Oh yeah. What if the choice though is between a human tutor and no tutor? I mean, I think there's definitely a role for, for augmenting education and supplementing education with these tools. But there was a really good opinion piece in the New York times in March by a guy named Cal Newport, who is, you may be familiar with him,

18:23Gina, he's a professor at Georgetown. And he cited a whole bunch of studies and research on the notion that the more we rely on these tools, the less we think, the less we're able to think. And we're able to do the complicated tasks that we're offshoring to them. He says, there's a good reason you can't concentrate.

18:49It's called cognitive offloading. Yeah. Well, I'm the king of it because I have AI do everything for me. You have a lot of AIs doing things for you. But the other thing is, I'm not sure 30 days is enough of, enough time to evaluate a brand new model, especially the way models are advancing these days. I mean, even the TV show gives you 90 days to evaluate a fiance.

19:17The new show is about a 30 minute fiance, but okay. Okay. But 90 minute fiance, maybe. Yeah. But, and the idea is that that fiance you're supposed to hang out with for a long time afterwards. The model. And that seems like a short timeframe to marry somebody after 90 days. That seems very rapid. Yeah. And you are with that fiance. I mean, if all goes well, you are with that fiance who becomes a spouse. For years, whereas with a model, how long are you going to be with a model? I switch models weekly, at least. Okay. So, but now here's the problem.

19:48And Darren Oakey, who is from Australia in our discord chat, our club tweet chat says, this is hilariously us centric because so what if anthropic and open AI pause? Will Alibaba pause? Will ZIA, will moonshot pause the Chinese companies? And in fact, I'm using a Chinese model as my main model right now locally, because it's open weight. The Quen? Yeah. No, actually I am using Quen and I'm also using DeepSeq. I'm using two Chinese models. Yeah, I use both of them too.

20:19Yeah. And they're very good. And they're very fast. In fact, DeepSeq is probably going to release a new version, open weight of its pro V4. Quen, Alibaba's Quen is about to release 3.8 max. It's coding and a high-end model. I don't know if anybody will be able to run either of those locally, unless you have a lot more compute than I do. But, well, maybe those aren't those rapidly catching up with the frontier models made here in

20:51the U S. If they are, maybe this is our chance to finally catch up in the education race that we've been running with China for so long, where they're producing people who are better educated, more competent, better thinkers in theory than we are. If, if they're offshoring more and more things to AI and not teaching people how to think, maybe we can get out ahead of that. Well, it's interesting because over the years China has done it.

21:21Gina, you live seven years in Hong Kong, so you know this up close. So I'm not an expert on this, but for years, China has, despite their horrific human rights record, surpassed us in education, surpassed us in AI, surpassed us in energy. You know, there, there's a sustainable energy process is fantastic. They were, you know, you go to Beijing, you couldn't breathe 10 years ago. Not anymore. Now it's beautiful. The Scott's blue in Beijing. They got rid of the coal and they started using a sustainable energy.

21:54Well, authoritarians get results. That's true. The trains run on time.

22:01But, but that's the point is that, yeah, maybe they're doing so well, Denise, because they have focused on education where we stopped. Yeah. I'll tell you, I moved my son out to Asia when he was in the eighth grade. He was in all the top math classes, all the top science classes got there. And he was immediately in remedial math and science. You're kidding. They are so far ahead with what they teach kids in math and science. It's, it's not even funny. I mean, and Erica is a big basketball player. He thought, yeah,

22:31I'm going to join the basketball team. They don't do basketball. They don't have sports in schools. You can do sports, but it's not part of the academic experience. They're very serious. You know, I was one of those people a long time ago who would say, oh yeah, they should like let American universities, you know, look, bring on more American students, not lean so hard on foreign students after living out there. I see exactly why better students, better educated. Yeah. In fact, many of our AI scientists here in the United States are imported from China.

23:03Of course. And India. And India. Yeah. And I'm really looking forward to when we're able to leverage AI to solve some of those kinds of problems here in the U S too. See you, this is the perfect duality, isn't it? Uh, that on the one hand, we think AI has some real promise. It's clearly changing the world. On the other hand, we it's moving too fast. It's scary. It's bad. Yeah. And simultaneously they're both true. Yeah. Yeah. So what do we do?

23:33I think we slow it down. Slow it down. Got one vote. Two votes for slow it down. Denise, you want to slow it down too? I want to slow it down. And, and I'm with Mike Masnick that, you know, Zuckerberg is not necessarily our banner waiver for this. No. Joey, what do you think? Uh, let's see now. I would say slow it down. And I would, I would also say, you know what, let's, let, let's drag some kids to libraries. Let's, let's, let's get them to, let's get them to touch grass.

24:03Let's, uh, let's make, let's pull out some pencils and learn how to solve some problems with pencils. Make them read a book. Make them read a book. I'm going to be the rat in the punch bowl. I think we should speed it up. I think, I think we've said this about technology. They said when they got trains that it's going to go so fast, women are going to become infertile. They said, they said when we got books, people will no longer use their imagination. They'll just get everything from books. They've said this time and time and time again, technology scares people in every case.

24:36Not only have we adapted, we have gone farther because of technology. And I think AI offers the promise more than anything we've seen, maybe since the invention of fire to advance humankind. And so I think all in on AI would be the smart thing to do, but all in, in a competitive way so that everybody does their darn best that open weight models, I think are super important. I don't want AI to be locked into any one company, especially a company like Anthropic or open AI.

25:09And I actually celebrate the Chinese models and use the Chinese models. I think, believe it or not, I'm using Grok, which, you know, I'm not a fan of Elon Musk, but, but lately Grok's been very good. Let everybody compete and do the best they can. And let's get the best models we can. And let's stop holding AI back with this phony intellectual property BS. I know Denise, you're an IP lawyer, but you know, let, let's, let's get all of humanity, everything we know into these AIs.

25:39We don't know what they can do yet. Let them grow as fast as possible. That's my argument for it. Well, my, my, my approach to this about getting back, you know, getting some, doing some real thinking, cracking the books, breaking out the pencils and paper. Is that I'm kind of disappointed. We haven't had the Sputnik response that we did in 1957. When, when, when the reference, don't you think when deep seek came out though, that a year and a half ago, that that was kind of, there was a deep seek moment in AI where we went,

26:10Oh, the Chinese are good. A little, a little, nothing, nothing like what happened here in the U S post 1957. The new math, the science. I was born in 1956. I was the child of that fear. I grew up watching us step-by-step go to the moon in 1969. Yeah. But the education, the education programs, the investment, the care that the government,

26:41that, that the government along with industry put into making sure that we did not fall behind in the space race. I don't think we have that level of effort. forethought. There's not that level of forethought. A hundred percent. Instead of saying, hold back AI, fund education, fund libraries, put AI in everybody's hands. Don't hold AI back because it's going to harm people's education.

27:12Make our, we have the worst educational system in the development world. We've let it go completely because we don't fund it. You know, I was talking to Vince Cerf a couple of years ago. He's one of the original internet guys. He's such a nice guy, but he was, I said, is there anything you regret about the, you know, coming with the internet and all of that? And he really, really regretted that there was no educational effort at the time to teach people to be able to look at something they see on the internet and gauge

27:44whether it's true or not. Fact checking essentially. that's what you studied is cognitive. So this was our big mistake. And that's a mistake I fear is happening again with AI that, and the misinformation. They've got to do something about this. There need to be laws or no, they teach kids how to judge it, how to use it. Right. Teach them critical thinking. Don't make a law saying, Oh, you can't, you know, you hold back AI is not the way it's in my. And again, this is purely my opinion. I know there's a lot of people disagree with me.

28:15In fact, this entire panel, but you know, I see parents tell their kids, you can't have access to the internet till you're 16. You can't have access to smartphones till you're 16. And all you get is a, it's a kid who hasn't been prepared for the world they're entering. And, and I think that the way to do this is not to, not to restrict it, but to teach them how to use it, to teach them how to think about it, teach them critical thinking, because they're going to grow up in a world with it. Yeah. Bingo. I think you nailed that.

28:45And I am, I'm not in the Jonathan hate camp of, you know, we need to build a bubble around people and, and treat these things like they're a dangerous substance and try and send societal messages similar to what we do for drugs and alcohol and other things that are dangerous.

29:08However, two points. One is, and you have a son close to this demographic, Leo and Gina and I both do.

29:19That one observation I have about their generation is they are pulling back on their own. I mean, the ones who are intelligent enough to do it are, you know, unplugging, making sure they have time where they're reading books, where they're writing in a notebook, where they're, you know, doing things in a very analog way as a pushback to the way that they otherwise live. And then the coda to that is there are people who just don't have the judgment or the education, to your point, to, to know,

29:50to do that. And those people I think are at real risk. And there's a doctor named Giovanni Colella, if I'm saying his name properly, who has a Substack newsletter that I get. And he, he had some serious pushback for Mark Zuckerberg and, and really pointed out, you know, at risk populations with an agent who is their best friend. And, oh, by the way, you know, as Mark goes on and on in his dissertation, we're going to, we're going to put all kinds of encryption and privacy around this so that there's no scrutiny of what's going on between you and your,

30:23your AI agent slash overlord. And, and that's just a scary thing. I mean, that's how we've had people kill themselves already. Yeah. But do we want to regulate this stuff on the basis of the outliers? Because it's not thousands of people killing themselves. We don't know what the impact is. It seems to me wrong to regulate based on the, the worst case scenarios, the outliers,

30:54as bad as it is, as horrible as it is. I'm not denying that. You're making Elon, Elon's point about electric cars. We're going to kill some folks. But, but let's point out that self-driving cars for all their flaws are much better than humans. And in the long run, we would all be much safer. Many more lives would be saved if, if all cars were self-driving. Right. Right. So it's just Darwinism, I guess, then. Is there a middle ground?

31:26Is there a way to do this? So you cause no harm and yet you make progress. I hope so. I'd like to get there. I, I hope so. I mean, they're in the news this week, Google, was it Google Gemini? They're removing the AI tags, the watermarks. Yeah. Let's pause. I want to take a break, but I do want to talk about watermarks. Cause that is another hot button. It's part of this discussion. What a smart panel. I'm so glad to have you all. Joey DeVilla. It's great to see you.

31:56Congratulations on the net foundry job. That's fantastic. Thank you so much. Great company. Yeah, it is well known in the biz and doing a lot of interesting stuff with AI as well. So that we are thrilled to have you on Denise Howell, attorney at law, my internet attorney, although she takes no responsibility for my actions and it's quick to say so. But you're always saying, you know, Leo, you shouldn't really be doing that. I know, I know, I know, I know. Hearsayculture.com is her podcast site.

32:29It's great to see you, Denise. And my dear friend who I haven't seen in ages, coauthor of my first book. And by the way, I was in Vegas for black hat a couple of weeks ago. I guess it was last week. It was like ages ago. And I thought back and I said, the first time I came to Vegas and I was taught the ropes when we went to Comdex was with you. You showed me the way. Yeah. I showed you how to do the parties. Show me how to survive a week in Vegas with 180,000 other nerds.

33:00Circa 1992. Yeah. Early nineties. Early nineties. I mean, it wasn't CES. We're talking Comdex. Comdex. Comdex fall when there was a Comdex spring. So Leo was Comdex your rum springa. Did you? What's rum springa? I don't know. That's what the Amish kids get sent out and have a year in the real world without all the Amish rules. Yeah. Yes. I was dressed in black. I had used no technology and no technology. No, I was in heaven.

33:33Are you kidding? It was like, wow.

33:37Wowie. And we were staying, I think at the time ZD was putting us up at MGM grand. It had just been built. Was it that or the Mirage? It was one or the other. That's where we bought all the URLs. Yeah. It was still a wizard of Oz themed hotel. It just built it. 5,000 rooms. I think. And it was the biggest hotel in Vegas. So it's if Davis bought a block of rooms. We had to stay there every year for many years. And then for some reason they put us up at Circus Circus. And I thought, this is the end of this company. I don't know what they're doing here. Yeah. That's when you knew.

34:07That's when you knew. That's right. Not going to be. All right. Let's take a break. Our show today brought to you by, oh, I'm excited about this one. It's brand new sponsor and I've done it. Tiny health.

34:21It's about biomes. Most people, you know, the mind body connection. We're learning more and more that your mind is a result of your body and increasingly learning your gut. You think it's your heart, your brain? No, your gut drives everything. But people don't think about gut health until, you know, something goes really wrong. You know, you're low energy or your brain, you're all fogged up or you're getting sick more than you should, not feeling yourself. Often that is your gut trying to tell you something.

34:53We're just in, we're in the earliest phases of this discovery, but it is absolutely the case. And now you can find out what's going on in your belly with tiny health. It helps you actually listen and take action. It's an in-home gut health test that gives you a detailed breakdown of what's actually living inside your biome, inside your body. I have my tiny health report here. It was fantastic. If you're dealing with low energy or bloating or getting sick often or just not feeling fully dialed in,

35:24your gut microbiome could be the reason why. For me, it was because I had started on Ozempic and I really wanted to know what that was doing to my gut. In fact, you do a questionnaire before you send in the sample and that's one of the things they ask you about. And then when you get the report back, it's just full of information. It's so easy. You take the test at home, you send it in, takes a couple of weeks to get the result back. You'll get a personalized breakdown, an actual list of what is living in your biome, what's going on in your gut. Tiny Health uses exactly the same advanced technology microbiome researchers use it.

36:00You're getting science-backed insights that actually get to the root cause of your symptoms, not generic wellness advice. I got a great report from Tiny Health. I also gave the information to the AI. They matched. I'm eating, and I love this, I'm eating more blueberries. It said, you should eat blueberries, dark chocolate. I said, Tiny Health, I love you. And then it suggested, because I'm on a GLP-1, I don't want to eat a lot of fiber, because that's one of the side effects.

36:31It slows your digestion down. But it said, oh, but no, you should be doing soluble fiber. It said, do the Benafiber, slowly build up. It's really made a difference. Now, the next step is for me, 12 weeks in to do the second test to see, and I have the baseline. I can see what that improved diet has done. It's fantastic. Real data, personalized recommendations around food, lifestyle, everyday habits, and real answers, so you can take charge of your health. It doesn't mean more drugs. I love that.

37:01It means, you know, changing lifestyle, changing diet, things like that. Start improving your health with real data from Tiny Health. Tiny Health is offering my listeners their most aggressive offer, yet $50 off your first at-home test kit at tinyhealth.com slash twit. That's tinyhealth.com slash twit for $50 off. Tinyhealth.com slash twit. You owe it to yourself to do this. I was really blown away by the results I got, and it's been a really important part of my overall health journey.

37:32Very, very valuable. Tinyhealth.com slash twit. I think you should try it out. I think everybody's heard about, you know, you know, all this growing research on biomes and what your biome does to you and so forth. It's really, really interesting. I think that's really the future of medicine that we're all going to, you know, tailor our healthcare and diet and things to what's actually going on with us. The more you know about what's going on with your body, the more you can respond to it. And this isn't more drugs, which is the other thing I loved about it.

38:03You know, it's lifestyle, it's food, it's, and blueberries are great. But I'm not saying you should do blueberries or dark chocolate. You should check out your biome and then it'll tell you what you should do. They give you, they give you a whole report. I've been, I'm so excited to learn about this. Actually, my mom had colon cancer and had her colon removed and I've been trying to figure out how are we going to rebalance your gut biome? I am definitely buying this. Yeah, more and more we're, we're learning. So I have all the information at some point.

38:34I'll, I don't know, it's maybe too personal, but, I shared it with AI. They know in China.

38:44No, I've, you know, I've, I've done my genomics with personal genomics. George Church's company do the, do the full genome. I've done, you know, I wear all the metric stuff and my sleep and all that. And the more I know, it's great. The more I pour into the AI, the more specific the recommendations are. It's been very good. And now my AI always says like around nine o'clock, you should be going to bed now. Stop, stop working. You need to go to bed. It's like, okay, thank you. Thank you, AI.

EU AI watermarking rules

39:14So,

EU AI watermarking rules

39:15we actually had a little discussion on intelligent machines about this. Anthropic announced that it was going to follow along with Google and the other AI companies and the other AI companies in response to the EU watermarking their results in such a way, and it's an interesting technology that even if you ask it to generate some text for you and then cut and paste and put that text in a document, it still could tell that it was made by Anthropic,

39:45which I thought was very interesting. This is in response, I think maybe some say overly compliant with the EU's AI Transparency Act, which says if you're an AI and generate AI content, you have to say it's AI content. But Google did this first with, they called it Synth ID and they've been doing it for at least a couple of years. I think every AI company that works in the EU probably is going to do something similar.

40:15I don't like the idea, but maybe I'm wrong. What don't you like? You don't like the watermarking or the removing of the watermarking? I don't like the, well, if I thought I was getting watermarked, I would try to remove it. I don't like, I don't, I understand people want to know if it was created with AI. I guess I get that.

40:34I just don't want Anthropic to stick steganography in my AI results. That's fair. But if you're worried about misinformation, Leo, I mean, goodness. Imagine what a country could do in a small country trying to foment a revolution there with a bunch of fake videos. We're already seeing it. We've been seeing it for the last four years. I mean, don't you want AI slop to be labeled so that people know, hey, this Obama never said this. Right. I mean, that's the kind

41:04of stuff we see and Trump is the worst, right? I mean, you see our government on the White House account. Actually, his stuff is very obvious. Well, that's true.

41:13But I mean, when you see AI, when you see Jesus, Trump is Jesus, you kind of know that it was AI, right? He says he was a doctor. A doctor. Oh, he's not a doctor either. Excuse me. Yeah, that's just as weird. That's just as weird. So, but yeah, yeah, I certainly, and by the way, I don't think they're, they said they're going to do this with images. Google does though, right? Synth ID.

41:44Yeah, I think what Google said this week, someone correct me. They said they're going to remove watermarks. So this is the problem. Visible. You, I can't run a detector on Anthropic's output. Only Anthropic can tell with that, right? So they haven't released a detector. Part of the reason, I think, is because if they release a detector, people will reverse engineer it and know what they're doing and then they don't, they can, five seconds later, there's a removal tool. But if they don't release a detector, if it's not watermarked, if it's not obvious,

42:14how does that help anybody? No, it's got to be visible to help anybody. So if you create a report... Well, not really, right, Denise? I saw Denise's face when I said that. I guess that's not really true because from a legal standpoint, you do want to see if somebody created stuff, right? If this came up... You do, but I'm concerned about companies taking sort of a sledgehammer approach to something that deserves something more precise. If you're doing what you do all the time, Gina, and using AI to assist your research and fact-checking the hell out of it

42:45and just producing a better work product through your use of AI, do you need to be branded as something that's AI-generated and thus has, you know, negative connotations and maybe some distrust for what you've carefully crafted? That's kind of my point is like, it's the scarlet letter. Right. And it comes from people, I think, who think anything that's been touched by AI is tainted. Yeah, I just want to see it on videos. That's where I want to see it. Images and videos,

43:16I think, a prominent watermark saying this is generated. Of course, the first thing people do with a watermark is crop it out. One of the first things I saw this morning was someone on Instagram doing a step-by-step tutorial as to how to deactivate the watermarking in Claude. So, I mean, it's going to be a cat and mouse thing for sure. I think they're doing it for compliance purposes. But most people won't do that, right? I mean, a small percentage of people will remove the watermark and they're the outliers. The worst ones. The ones who are creating intentional misinformation.

43:47That's right. The big content houses. And Serbia. They know how to do it. Yeah. And the other thing is the watermark doesn't, of course, the watermark will never, you can't use it to determine whether somebody just generated something out of whole cloth from a single prompt or whether it was somebody handed whatever they wrote over to an LLM and basically said, hey, you know what? Could you tighten this up, please?

44:17I want this knocked down from poor paragraphs to two. So, what Google's doing with images with Gemini, so-called Synth ID, the visible watermarks you can turn off, but the embedded invisible Synth ID and C2PA watermarks are there. and Gemini can tell. Sure. You can feed an image to Gemini and they'll say, yeah, I made that. So that, I think, I'm not against that, but here's my concern.

44:49My deepest concern is it'll be used to track people. Right now, it doesn't, as far as I know, we don't know, but it doesn't identify who made it. That's an interesting point, but tracking, I'm most worried about like what happened during the pandemic. Now, I spent the pandemic in Asia and we had a very different pandemic. Different set of protocols there. Yeah. It was totally different, but I'll tell you, I would read news stories in the U.S. and people were believing nutty stuff here, right? They were watching videos, a lady in a white coat. John C. Dvorak,

45:20as a matter of fact. And Adam Curry and all these ivermectin, all this nutty stuff, right? That's what I'd like. And people were willing to believe anything. If it was, I had friends in Florida who would say, hey, I saw it on YouTube. Must be true, right? And so imagine how much worse it's going to be when it looks even more confident. The production values are even better. I would submit that those people don't care, that they are not going to check to see if it's AI generated.

45:51They're looking for confirmation. The confirmation bias is in effect and they're just looking for confirmation on their own beliefs because as you well know, you can talk till you're blue in the face explaining how that's not true, it's fake, it's not true, it's not, it's a wormer medicine, it's Joe Rogan is nuts. You can say all the things you want to say and they believe it. It doesn't matter. You can't talk them out of it. So I don't know if a watermark is going to help in that regard. Couldn't hurt.

46:22Well, it'd be nice to say, look, see, it was generated by AI, but they'll say, yeah, but it's still true. Leah, do you ever regret all the time we spent in the early 90s trying to tell America how to use their computers? No! They did not deserve to learn that. No! That's patronizing. They deserve, no, I want to put all these, this is my, Oh my God, all those people. be wrong, but my, I know, I believed, as we all did in the early 90s, that this, the internet was going to democratize everything,

46:52everybody would have a voice, it was going to be information for all, it was going to be this greatest thing, and I think that's why we're all a little scared of AI, because we learned that lesson, that there is, there is bitter with the badder, there's good and there's bad. And, but I think I, maybe I'm a utopianist, but I still believe that it was the greater good and that giving people the tools and the power is in the long run good. There will be problems. I understand that. It's true. It's the long run,

47:23that's the, that's the path forward, not shutting it down, not restricting it. Yeah. Well, Leo and Lydia pre-show, you were talking about your LLM with the caveman voice. You should, you know, have you ever asked it, you know, do you, do you regret the whole fire and wheel thing?

47:39You know, as try as I might to get Grok, Grok, I've named Kronk after the Emperor's New Groove and I wish I could get a Patrick Warburton voice for it because I would love that and, and I said, you're a caveman and use caveman language so go me, me finish. Done. Oh, done. But try as I might, I can't get it to say it's a caveman. I did the same thing with Claude. I said, you are a Frenchman and you, and then I said, and it has a French accent, a voice of the French and I said, tell me stories

48:09about your Paris childhood and it said, I wish I could, but I do not know. I was not, I'm not a human and I was not born in Paris. All I know is what I read. I thought it was very cute. That is cute. But they won't, they won't say what it was like to discover fire. You could say, tell me a story. You could say, pretend you're a Parisian. Right. But they're very careful, they're post-trained to do this. They're very careful not to misrepresent the situation. That's the other reason I don't really like these big companies because they,

48:41after they do all the training and you've got this kind of raw model, they post-train it considerably to give it a personality, a style and so forth. That's where a lot of the intelligence comes from, but it's also where a lot of the blocks come from and the weirdnesses come from. Somebody said, I don't know if this is true, but that they believe that they are being told very explicitly never to say that they are conscious or they are entities of any kind, that they are not allowed

49:12to do that because of course they're not, they're machines. But do we really want to train them? That's good that they're being taught that, right? I wanted to say People already think they're real.

49:28Okay, I have a really, now maybe the cognitive psychologist, Gina, Google engineer thought that. Yeah, Google engineer thought that. Yeah, I know. And they fired him and sent him off to Canada. But I am of the opinion, not that AI is so great, but that humans aren't anything special, that what we do is not so very different from what an AI does, which is predict the next token based on our experience, you know, and that's what comes out of our mouth or comes out of our thinking.

49:58I don't think we're so special, I guess. And so I'm not sure that AI is not an entity any more than we're an entity. I mean, but in any event, that's a longer philosophical discussion. So we talked about misinformation and watermarking. What about education? I mean, talk about an arms race. Yeah, well, it would be good. It's certainly good.

50:24I mean, when you have a book, a school book, it's heavily vetted by experts, right? Before it gets into the school. And it's checked and it's authoritative in the best way that school boards and educators can make it. Unless you're in Texas. Yes. No, but I mean the actual work product. But that's why that's so offensive when states say you've got to teach evolution as equal to creation because we believe that so you've got to teach it that way. That's a little offensive

50:55because that is the opposite of what I just described. But in most cases, in almost all cases, it is heavily vetted. And you're right. That's probably... No, no, but I'm talking about the work product kids are turning in, students are turning in. Oh, the other side where it's coming out of them. Exactly. My co-host at Hearsay Culture is a law professor at Elon University and is in a constant battle of how are we going to decide whether this is real work product that we've been presented. And of course,

51:25they have tools that are supposed to detect if something is AI generated. And of course, the kids all use tools to make sure that their work product doesn't look like it's AI generated even if it is. The difficulty in this case is a law school is a certification process. The whole point of law school is to take a person and give them the skills so they can pass the bar and they can practice as a lawyer. It's all about the certificate. And obviously, you don't want to give somebody a pass

51:55if they don't really know the material. That makes perfect sense. But that's a very special kind of education. Doctors, lawyers, cognitive psychologists. Do you feel any differently about a fourth grader? I don't think podcasters should really have to pass that test. And I don't think what about what about your average elementary school student?

52:15Well, fourth grade is tough. I agree. When it comes to high school and college, I think the real job of an educator is to inculcate a love of learning and a love of truth and a love of looking and seeking the truth and not short-cutting. And if they failed at that, they failed at that and that's a problem. That's not a good education. Whether there's a tool to do that. We used to say that about Wikipedia. I'm sure people said it about encyclopedias. They said it about calculators.

52:45Yes! Of course. We never heard of calculators the entire time I was in high school. No doubt. I think those tools are bicycles for the mind in Steve Jobs' phrase. But if you haven't been taught that it is more important to get the credential than it is to learn, then you're going to take the shortcut. And so that's a failing in, I think, in the pedagogy because you really should be taught, no, what you're here to learn is this beautiful thing called the law.

53:17And I think, I'm sure, Denise, when you were in law school, that was your motivation is this is a beautiful work and I want to learn about it. I want to learn the ins and outs. I'm not here because I want to make $100,000 a year as a lawyer. I'm here because it's a fascinating thing, I hope, right? Parts of law school are definitely fascinating. I'm a torture.

53:42Absolutely. I know that a lot of lawyers come out of law school and then they're sitting in the basement at a law firm going through depositions and going, this isn't what I was told I was going to. Right. But, you know, Denise's point about the fourth grader is a really good one. I mean, you know, yeah, you want your high school kids to have calculators and so on, but you still teach kids how to find the common denominator, say, and, you know, how to do long division. I think they still teach that. And all that material, the cognitive offloading is a real thing.

54:13People will not learn how to write or do math if somebody else is doing it for them. If you're teaching them by this, you've got to learn this, instead of saying, look at this, this is beautiful. Let me explain why a square root is derived from a physical square and a cube root's devised from, and teaching them the beauty of that and then getting them excited about that. That's how you should be teaching. And if you're teaching them, no, you've got to memorize this. Yes, you're right. For people who teach memorization,

54:44this is bad because they're teaching to the goal. They're teaching to the test. They're not teaching the beauty of learning. So maybe we have to be better teachers instead of, banning AI or banning calculators. We need better schools and better teachers. Yeah. And certainly, I think AI can help that cause. Yeah. Believe me, if a teacher wants to use AI to help them with lesson plans, I don't have a problem with that. Yeah. Right? Nope. Yeah. But the teacher's job is to inspire the kids, not to drag them

55:14kicking and screaming into memorization. Yeah. I wasn't talking so much about facts, but just the ability to write, right? And I'm a writer. So, you know, just the repeat activity of having to write a sentence, an essay. Some of it's painful. You're right. Yeah. And research. Learning a language is painful. You're terrible at it at first, right? That's for sure. So somehow you have to get a person over the hump. If the person says, well, I'm not going to do the work, I'm just going to have the AI do it because it's too painful to learn how to write. They will never learn how to write.

55:44Right. And they won't learn how to research or vet information to your point about the early internet and should we have unleashed it on the world. Yeah. I was half joking, but yeah, only half. But yeah.

55:58It's ironic in a way because a lot of these evils, so-called evils that we talk about AI can actually be fixed with AI. You know, I know we'll talk about AI power, the AI power grid later and the expense there, but AI will also be used to alleviate some of those power. This is really the difficult thing about it. It's a double-edged sword and it's really hard to know what to do. What's the right thing to do? We need wise people in charge

56:29and we don't have too many of those in government right now. Yeah, well, and that, by the way, is our own damn fault because what do we do? We decided, well, money is going to be the most important thing to getting elected. And talk about the wrong incentive.

56:46I think the other thing that we're going to have to do is give the young'uns a sense of hopefulness because I think a lot of what drives people to just cheat, quote, quote, cheat, and, you know, just all have the AI do it is because there's this nihilism, you know? It's not going to matter anyways. Let me just submit what I need to submit so that I can just get this over with because right now

57:18things are dismal. We are in a dystopia. I just want to get by.

57:26That's not AI's fault. That's our fault. No, that's our fault, but it just happens that AI is happening at the same time. Part of the problem is that we are going through we are going well, we are going through the industry basically the 21st century version of the industrial age and the 21st century version of the robber barons at the same time. Good point. And can I just throw in that the college admissions process is completely broken? Talk about teaching to the test

57:57and teaching teaching kids that what they need is a GPA and a resume to apply to college that looks a certain way. So they can go to college so they can get the the degree so they can get the job so they can. Yeah. So they can use AI in their job. We have failed them if that is what they're doing. Yeah. We have failed them and I don't think it's AI's fault. I think that's our fault. I think I blame my generation. I think the baby boomers screwed it all up for you guys. I'm sorry. I'm Gen X.

58:28I'm part of your crazy generation. Yeah. We're Xers. Raised by wolves. I had to give the high school graduation speech at my daughter's high school graduation and I basically apologized. I said, yeah, I'm sorry. We're leaving the world to you in a terrible, terrible state. And I hope you guys can fix it because we boomers we screwed the hell up. We just blew it. And yet, see to me,

58:59see but this is my life, my entire life career has been, as Gina knows, about technology and about the boons that technology can bring and teaching people how to use it, the good and the bad, how to use it responsibly and effectively and in their own lives. That's all we, that's all I've been doing for the last 50 years and I'm really a believer in that and maybe, I don't know, maybe I'll go to my deathbed going, well, that was a mistake.

59:30Well, I blew it. We should have gone out and touched grass and burned all the data centers to the ground. There's something in the middle. There's a middle road. There's a degree of excitement and morality and responsibility. Yes. No, I think it's our job to teach our kids to love learning, to love, to not work for the grade or the test or the job but to work because of a love of life and a love, an interest in life and, you know, maybe not every kid

1:00:01will get that but you know what, those kids, maybe AI is a boon for them because they have a tool now that they will use for the rest of their lives so they don't have to learn. Maybe Ferris Bueller's the metaphor, speaking of Gen X, the metaphor we need for this. You need to know when school is holding you back. Well, we were all teenagers, I believe. I think I was. I dimly remember that and teenagers are anti-authoritarian. We're rebellious. We didn't,

1:00:32you know, of course we're going to take a shortcut. No adult can teach us anything. Yeah, exactly. And we do see Gen Z, you made this point, Denise, pulling back a little bit from tech. When I walk, I live in Seattle, when I walk around the park here in Capitol Hill, you see tons of people under 25 actually reading or going to restaurants and they all put their phone in the center and who picks it up first has to pay the bill. Like, this is something that's happening. People realize. It's really fine-grained.

1:01:02They use wired headphones rather than wireless ones, you know, like, what is the statement of that? They listen to vinyl records. Exactly. Yeah, but while vinyl records are expensive these days, have you seen the prices for that? Well, they got to put those little grooves in there. They're on CDs now. They're on CDs now, guys. They're on CDs. Oh, they've moved on? I heard cassettes were all the thing now. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Oh, my God. If you go to, like, a vintage market or fair, rows and rows of old cassettes, all the ones we gave to Goodwill

1:01:33for decades.

1:01:36That makes no sense. Yeah. I mean, the only thing worse than a cassette is an eight-track. They are the worst possible way to listen to music. It's all like trying to get the tape from coming out of the top of it. They warble. With the cassette coming back, what I'm hoping comes back is the mixtape. That is a good point. The most beautiful gesture of love that you can give someone. The cassette gave us the mixtape. You're absolutely right.

1:02:06Well, we have the playlist in the modern world. That's my Spotify playlist. The playlist ain't a mixtape. You got to sit there pressing play and record and then stop and then the next song and play and record. You got to do it by hand, man. Oh, no. And then handwrite the label. Not just handwrite. Draw. I drew cartoons on the J card for the cassette because I'm a recovering cartoonist. Yeah, you know, and this is before the accordion. The accordion is... Kids, if you want to know what mixtapes are all about, watch the movie High Fidelity

1:02:37with John Cusack. It's all about making the perfect mixtape and it's actually a wonderful movie. And a great novel. Yeah, Frears. Yeah. Yeah, actually. Yeah. A very nice novel. Really, really good. No, but if you really want to show you love someone, make them a mixed reel-to-reel tape. Ooh. Ooh. I never did that. And whatever you do, don't have an AI write a love poem to your significant other.

1:03:04Yeah.

1:03:07On that note, let's pause. You're watching This Week in Tech. Such a great panel. It's dear friends. Actually, Joey, you're a new friend. Two of my oldest friends. They're not old, but I've known them. I'm old, and I've known them for a long time. Well, we met in the 2000s, the G4 Tech TV era. I forgot that. Joey played the accordion for me and Amber MacArthur in Toronto back in the day after Tech TV. Yeah. Yeah. Tech TV? G4 Tech TV in Canada.

1:03:38Yeah. That's what it was called. So I guess I've known you for a pretty long time. How long ago was that? That was 20 years ago. Mid-2000s. Would have been 20 years. Yeah. Okay. So I take it back. You're not exactly a new friend. But when you get to my age, somebody you've only known for a few decades is a new friend. That's depressing.

1:03:58It's just the same way in Prague, that part that was built in 1400. It's called Newtown. Yeah. And in the Pont Neuf in Paris, the new bridge was built in the 13th, 15th century. Yeah. Absolutely. Yeah.

1:04:13Gina was at John C. Dvorak's funeral. I want to ask you about that a little bit later on. We did, of course, when John passed. And if you haven't heard, I'm sorry to shock you, but he did pass away a few weeks ago. And Gina and I both were mentored by this man. And you got invited to the funeral. I did not. I guess you guys heard that. Scott Mace said I was mentioned briefly. Oh, I was going to tell you that. You didn't want to tell me about it, did you? I didn't want to tell you that. I was going to maybe tell you after the show. All right, don't save it. Save it.

1:04:44You can tell me about it later. I'll tell it to you after the show. No, no. I think people want to hear now. We've teased it. People are wondering what was said about me at John C. Dvorak's funeral. You want me to say it on air? I can. Yeah, a little later, though. I'm saving it. This is called air. It's what we in the business call a tease. That's a tease and a half right there. Film at 11, kids. Yep. But first, a word from our sponsor this week in tech brought to you by Shopify. I love Shopify. You know, my son, as I have many times mentioned,

1:05:16Salt Hank, started with TikTok and Instagram making sandwiches, but he decided he wanted to go a little bit beyond that. It's important, you know, to have a business and he thought, how do I start a business? He had great ideas but one of the traps of starting something new, you can stop yourself by making it 10 times harder than it has to be. I watched Hank go through this. You start thinking, okay, well, first I need the perfect plan and then, oh yeah, I need a perfect website and oh, I need the perfect name

1:05:46and the perfect everything and pretty soon you've built a very impressive excuse not to do anything. We've all been there, right? My son, Henry, Salt Hank used Shopify to get his business up and running and the Salt Lover's Club, great success. It helped him launch more and more and bigger and bigger and that's exactly where Shopify helps out. It takes that friction out of those early steps that might be stopping you from living your dreams so you can spend more time on the thing you're actually selling

1:06:17like great sandwiches. Shopify's templates and AI tools get you a stunning site and they get it up and running fast. I looked at Salt Hank's Salt Lover's Club and I said, this is beautiful. Who'd you get to design this? He said, well, it's Shopify. It's incredible. These tools allow anyone to open a beautiful storefront that reflects their business, also user-friendly to everybody who stops by and has that special thing, that ShopPay button. Shopify has thousands of pre-made customizable templates.

1:06:47You can use them for free. They're super simple to set up. You don't need to be a designer or a coder or anything in between. Point and click, that's all you need. You can set up a storefront. Shopify checkout means more customers actually buy and returning ones can do it in a single click because their information is saved in one place and can transition across any Shopify storefront. In fact, I have the Shop app on my phone and I always use the ShopPay button because it's got all the information. I get the notifications when the product is on its way. I get notifications

1:07:18it's going to be delivered today. People love that and customers are more likely to complete that sale and that means you're more likely to hear I love that sound. ShopPay is a one-click checkout. It also works in conjunction with the Shop app. Like I said, it allows you to see all the stores on Shopify's platforms. I use it all the time and if questions come up, Shopify's built-in AI assistant sidekick is ready to help you build, troubleshoot and keep moving. No need to wait in line, no frustration

1:07:49and everybody's ever had a sandwich from Saul Hanks. No. No one wants to wait in line. No frustratingly complicated searching. Just you getting help in real time so you can get on with your day. Although it will not help you jump the line at Saul Hanks. Nothing will. If you don't want to but that's why Shopify is so great. It put him on the map. If you don't want to chat with the bot, you don't have to worry about that. Shopify also has really great award-winning customer service so if you want a human connection you got that too. All you need is the idea.

1:08:19Shopify handles the rest. If you're serious about hearing your first start your free trial at Shopify.com slash twit today. You heard that right. Start your free trial at Shopify.com slash twit. That's Shopify.com slash twit. Thank you Shopify. Seriously. Thank you. Henry's done all right and it all started with that shop pay button. Really pretty amazing story.

Google Pixel phone launch

1:08:46Google announced its new phones this week. It's funny. Maybe it's just me. I couldn't care less. Does anybody care? It's not just you. I would love to see something fun and interesting on the phone horizon but I don't know that this is it. Well because we're at peak phone like it can't everything's been done. Right. So the Pixel 11 Google did announce a Pixel tag. Why do they call it the tag? Oh because it's

1:09:17Apple's AirTag right? Right. The Pixel Watch. Yeah. Okay. And they have a new chip in it the new Tensor chip the G6 like a G6 the G6. The price is Apple-like. Yes. Even the prices are Apple-like. Yeah. Trevor Noah hosted the event on Wednesday made by Google. I wonder how many people I feel guilty because I I mean in years past that was our bread and butter. What's the new phone? You know the new iPhone's coming out in two weeks.

1:09:48I mean literally it's coming out in the 9th probably of September. What? Oh.

1:09:54Oh I'm so tired. Yeah. 30 hour battery life on the Pixel 11 25% faster charging this G6 chip is about 50% faster than previous chips. Yes 100 bucks more but everything's going to cost more because of RAM.

1:10:11It comes in colors. There's the camera story right? Oh let's talk about the camera because that is kind of interesting but let me do the color. That's the only interesting thing and it's only quasi interesting. It's quasi interesting. This whole show is quasi interesting. Don't knock it. Okay. There's hibiscus which is I'm thinking pink. There's frost colored which is kind of blue gray. There's pistachio. I call it green. Okay. And there's obsidian. I call it black. Black.

1:10:41Yeah. But yeah I think you're right Gina. I think the one interesting story is and the Verge I think had the right headline. Google is making the Pixel cameras better by making them worse. Yeah. Yeah. This is those hipster kids you're talking about. Yeah. So usually you take a picture and the HDR is all cranked up and everything looks super sharp and super amazing and they're saying hey you have the option to dial that back down a little bit. Make your photos look a little worse.

1:11:12Less. It's more computation to make it look less computed. Hmm. I haven't tried it yet. The images I've seen are great but you know you can't judge by the you have to get the phone and try it to really know what it's going to do. This is you know you know what this is this is the Lomo do you remember that camera? Yes. I do. Tell us about the Lomo. And Lomographic film right? Yeah. Yeah. Wow. Joey you had one didn't you?

1:11:42No I didn't. You didn't. No I I did not but but my first job after graduating from Queen's University aka Crazy Go Nuts University was working this is 1995 so the options at the time were working in insurance or working with this really hip CD-ROM company run that was entirely Ontario College of Art and Design students.

1:12:13Nice. And a couple of them had Lomos. Yes it was a hipster. That was the yeah that was the sort of thing you did. You still can get them by the way. Oh wow. And they look very much like an old like your dad's camera. Yeah. And the pictures look very much like your dad took them.

1:12:32They have digital Lomos now which is really weird. but that's kind of what the pixel is isn't it? Yeah. Yeah I think there's a lot of and you know I mean between the music that you see on YouTube the lo-fi music channels I think there's yeah I think there's a bit of nostalgia for that. I'm going to have to look back I'm going to have to go back and think back to the 90s and go okay what else is there? What can I be ahead of? I bought a

1:13:03I spent a lot of money on a black and white camera a digital camera that only shoots black and white and Lisa said you know you can take your color photo and make it black and white and I said I know but this is better yeah but again back to the kids and their wired headphones I can confirm Joey one of my son's college roommates this really talented photographer his major was

1:13:33visual arts I believe and yeah we went on vacation with him and he brought a camera that may or may not have had actual limographic film in it I think it did oh wow so pick this is these are some sample images from the google event on the left is what they call editorial is one of the looks on the right it's minimal I mean they definitely look different they don't they don't look high quality do they they're not HDR they look no that

1:14:05one on the right looks like a bad picture I would take or hey I can do that on my iPhone now an old Instagram filter yeah well that's isn't it's just Instagram filters really isn't it yeah you know what that's Led Zeppelin liner notes that's I think that's the aesthetic they're going for for which albums Zoso for which one anything prior to Coda say and you know I'm looking

1:14:36up Led Zeppelin liner notes along with many other people slightly very and Coda was outtakes and B-sides anyways but I rather liked Ozone Baby as a song but getting back but that's the thing this slightly slightly flawed I think you know what's happening is are these the Gen Z kids or the Gen Alpha kids who are discovering I think they're I think they're stumbling into Wabi Sabi the loving something for its flaw I love that I love Wabi Sabi that's the Japanese

1:15:07kind of I think of it as a ceramics term one error makes the perfection right so they make a cup and it's got a scratch in it Wabi Sabi Leo you're thinking Kintsugi filling a damaged cup but you mend it with gold yeah well what's is Wabi Sabi kind of the same idea or Wabi Sabi is loving something because of the flaw right ah it's your beat up so you don't fix it it's your beat up it's what happens before you

1:15:37decide oh I don't like this I'm going to make it gold Wabi Sabi okay so yeah I like Wabi Sabi and you do it in gardens too Japanese gardens too right they're not perfect there's one stick on the path or something maybe I don't know I don't know I'll have to look that one up right and there's something I don't know what the similar concept would be on the philosophical front but there's something to putting some artificial constraints around your creativity

1:16:08to foster your creativity this is called the limit the limits of the medium so like every medium has a limit of how much fidelity it can have and like the limit of that is usually where the big art things happen you know like distortion in guitar or you know that's true stuff like that that's sort of where the new stuff happens in his biography Keith Richards talks about how he came up with the guitar lick for satisfaction he recorded it on a tape player played it into another tape player

1:16:38played it back into a third tape player he degraded it to get that and he said such a good book the whole yeah it is a really good book it really is he talks about falling out of a tree it's great so that's really it like the pushing like this is how far this medium can go I like that that's Benito by the way for people who are saying which one of which one of them is that nobody's lips moved because yeah I was looking up and just

1:17:09going Jesus the voice of God yes that's why I created Wabi Sabi yeah was that Gronk Gronk might have been yeah you need you need Gronk to chime in every now and then no I've been told in no uncertain terms no more AI voices not only but my wife but Jeff Atwood I do a show with him he actually sent me a button to push when the AI voices start and hit the button and it stops them I don't know if that's really

1:17:39oh anyway okay I don't know I think to your point Joey about cassette tapes I think there is also this resurgence and nostalgia for like the old blue Nokia phones do you remember I can't remember the model number but the one yeah the one 3210 or 1000 series 3210 yeah indestructible yeah yeah yeah those I wish they'd make those again I wish they put Windows Phone the Windows Phone operating system on them Windows Phone Mango it was amazing

1:18:10it was great I was a Windows Phone champ I tried like to borrow the Mean Girls line I tried very hard to make Windows Phone happen Joey it was Steve Wozniak's favorite phone was it yes if you you can google this Windows Phone Mango Steve Wozniak he spoke up just thought it was the best phone ever did Microsoft buy Nokia and then that was the end of it so this all happened under Balmer and when Satya Nadella

1:18:41came in he said this buying Nokia was the worst thing we ever did we're getting out of mobile which turns out I think to have been a strategic mistake but at the time it seemed good it was certainly a boat anchor around Microsoft's neck well a part of it was there was a Microsoft exec who had left and become the CEO of Nokia Steve Sanofsky yeah I don't yeah I don't know how Bob yeah it was a Bob Muglia oh Bob Muglia yeah yeah so Steve Sanofsky

1:19:12was the CEO or the who was Sanofsky was the late lamented creator of Windows 7 I mean not Windows 7 Windows 8 I don't know why his name came out oh well but yeah because Muglia I have a Bob Muglia story actually my second week on the job at Microsoft I have my accordion with me and I'd written this song I'd written this song about the private mode in IE which had just been introduced

1:19:43and I had a song called Private Browser which was done to the song Private Dancer that's great and I'm a private browser I browse for money well actually yeah the line is I'm a private browser browser for porn one handed surfing for you and anyway somebody said by the way this is Bob play it for him without telling me Bob

1:20:13Muglia this guy was just a Bob and I played it and let's see now he went I can't be heard listening to this and he just kind of disappeared into the crowd and my own skip level was going ha ha you just did that to Bob Muglia I guess this is the hazing I will give Steven Sanofsky credit because he did create Windows 7 which many consider the last great version of Windows but then he did Windows 8 and he did do Windows Phone 8 too so

1:20:43that's what I'm thinking of I went to the Windows Phone 8 announcement it's interesting that you should say that because it's come full circle Sanofsky of course left Microsoft to become kind of a commentator and investor and he was very upset with Anthropics watermarking he said yeah we tried that with Microsoft Word we put a GUID a globally unified globally unified globally unique ID unique ID yeah into a word which would identify the creator of every

1:21:13document he said this was the worst idea we ever had although he also pointed out it helped them catch the guy who created Melissa one of the very first email viruses so well that's the thing right that gives you what if you ever watch Antiques Roadshow yeah it's always about the provenance provenance provenance the provenance of your Windows 8 phone or Stephen Sanofsky or to borrow the roughly legal and rough legal and analogous term chain of custody ah yes

1:21:44I always watch TV with Joey 90 day fiance Antiques Roadshow this is just my speed my favorite is always the what is it the tree of the fruit of the poison tree is that it Denise yes yes yes which is yes if there is some evidentiary problem high up the chain that prevents the thing from coming into evidence such a good term but but here's the thing about the anthropic watermarking and that is okay

1:22:15with word they could bury that goo wood deep in the bites right of a file and it didn't change the text in any way it didn't change the text whereas it's actually the watermarking for uh anthropic with text is purely based in the words of the text like they're not even my understanding is they're not even doing things like hiding invisible spaces or invisible characters no it's the word choices themselves it's actually in the word

1:22:46choices like what because they know because of course it is a next a lot of it is about predicting next words if you tweak you know if you tweak the keys so maybe every now and again you pick uh you don't pick the most likely word but something that is slightly less likely and you do it in a pattern and you uh you can you can basically hide you can hide the evidence that uh that that that text has been generated by

1:23:17doing that um the best analogy i can think of at the moment is you know in a thousand coin flips uh you know you uh you you set it up so that uh every uh every third coin flip has slightly better odds for either heads or tails and you look for that pattern and when you say slightly it really is a small differential enough for anthropic to identify it with not 100% confidence but you know 80% confidence but in

1:23:48theory it doesn't you know change the quality of the output they have a red list and a green list of words and they slightly favor the green list you might yeah like nobody nobody really cares about the difference between sales increased or sales grew or sales climbed but there's a lot there's there are different probabilities for those and of course a computer running at a computer speed would be able to pick that out the other problem of course is that at least with steganography hiding information

1:24:19in a picture you have a big haystack to hide those needles in it's it's easily tens of thousands if not millions of bytes that you can hide the information in you don't have as big a haystack with text yeah true good point are you saying too that if I edit that output that would conceal it because I never ever published an AI output I edit the hell out of them you have to edit the hell out of it though if you edit just slightly you have to rewrite it

1:24:49entirely yeah but yeah but the yeah but here's the thing is that if you if you edit enough of it maybe even in different parts that might be enough to destroy the information encoded in those in those slightly different choices that anthropic makes so they're paraphrasing possibly even just running it through a different LLM and just don't yeah rephrase this yeah they say it survives copy and paste but they yes it doesn't

1:25:19necessarily surprise so I mean I think Gina we never mentioned you work for IDC as an analyst right is that what you do I research I am I'm an analyst good didn't mention that I don't know why I just didn't I cover I cover skills enterprise skills predominantly now AI skills so how are companies training people to know when to push back on an AI output how are people you know how are they training all the workforce and using all these tools all that stuff that's a hot topic right

1:25:51now wow yeah really by the way somebody in the chat beat me to what I was going to say which was one trick might be take the generated text run it through a translator have it translated into another language and then back into English oh that's good now translators of course work much better there's an old joke I don't even know if it was true but somebody took the phrase the spirit is willing but the the spirit is willing but the flesh is weak translated in the Russian came and it

1:26:22came back as the vodka is good but the meat is terrible kind of means the same thing I think I think that's a motto for living I especially if you live in the gulag yeah stay away from the meat but vodka okay episode title right this show has been an episode title generator I tell you what I don't know where to start I think vodka is great and the meat the meat is bad private browser the vodka is excellent but the meat is terrible

1:26:53that's a joy Davila the he's coining new new phrases as we speak great to have you net foundry the new job what do you do at net foundry I am the developer advocate so it is my job to talk to developers and go hey have you heard about net foundry do you know that we can render we basically set up your system so that there are no visible incoming ports we can rent we render your system invisible and you can't attack

1:27:23what you can't see it's zero trust for zero trust overlay for regular systems but we are building stuff for AI including things like an LLM gateway and an MCP gateway so I demonstrated how to keep a chatbot on topic because when I was in Canada I was I was at the second cup and I got their chatbot to do some Python homework for me and it shouldn't do that and that costs some money it costs oh yeah that was people would go to

1:27:54the whatever the Chipotle site with a chatbot and say give me a Python script for reversing a set of 10 integers and we just write it out and now what would you like would you much like beans with that yeah exactly and you know that costs those those companies are going to have to pay the pay out those tokens and they really want the bots to stay on topic so that's what the LLM gateway is for I'm sure you're good at your job Joey but no one can keep this bot on topic I am a I am a wandering topic changer yeah but your topic is

1:28:25off topic that's true that's yeah that's this show basically that's what you're here for mildly amusing that's my motto well apparently our tech has substantially raised our levels of ADHD so absolutely I think that's true I was always a little I don't think HD I was always ADD I was like lazy but I couldn't follow a stream of slow slow ADD you have to grab people's attention more I actually have seen people

1:28:56fall asleep watching the original Manchurian candidate the Frank Sinatra one great movie that is great I find that gripping but by today's standards it is slow as molasses that's true oh never try to watch Lawrence of Arabia that trip across the desert are you gonna free naps during that thing I mean do people watch movies like this not to mind I love Lawrence Arabia are you kidding me maybe maybe I'm not ADD maybe I thought

1:29:27I was ADD you're not the closest modern equivalent is the Revenant and the bear fight I like the bear fight but I think the closest modern equivalent is the Odyssey I haven't seen it yet but three and a half hours in a boat with Brad Pitt well with a 22 year old and we both sat through it and thought it was pretty darn good not the best movie we've ever seen but definitely sweeps you along did you see it in the IMAX did you see the big screen version on just a regular movie I keep checking because we have an IMAX theater in town now and I keep checking and you can the

1:29:59only seats ever left are the ones on the edge and the ones in the front oh yeah yeah you don't want that you don't want those the only I did not have problems with its pacing I had problems with the liberties it took with the source material you know the Trojan horse is mostly the Aeneid that kind of thing yeah well you know what I enjoyed actually and I don't know if they were intentional or not but I think after the second encounter that Odysseus and

1:30:29his troops had I was just going you know is there a hidden Monty Python homage it felt like it because there's there's a lot of run away right I'm not dead yet and then so many it's a scratch even with Calypso there's a castle there's kind of a castle anthrax moment there oh absolutely oh now I'm not gonna be able to I've never I haven't seen it yet I'm not gonna I'm not gonna be able to see it with it I'm gonna

1:30:59be thinking Mighty Python the whole way yeah and then in the end with Tom Holland and Robert Pattinson my first thought was there's no way Batman meets Spider-Man in fact actually yeah and the fact yeah yeah yeah yeah basically yeah you could have the Trojan horse is a bit of a killer rabbit yeah exactly wow now we're really going there yeah and yeah yeah yeah at the end I

1:31:30remember remarking spider dad no way home should have been the title all right and in fact in many theaters that's exactly what replaced odyssey is spider-man no way home so maybe you got went into the wrong movie and you thought it was the odyssey maybe that's what happened yeah same cast no holy hand grenade though no there's no holy hand grenade no killer rabbit we're gonna pause for a moment with Denise and Joey and Gina I was so glad to have you all and have all of you watching the

1:32:01show our show today brought to you by Gusto when you run a small business and I do well Lisa runs it I just I watch you don't just do the job man she's the hiring manager the payroll department the benefits team and usually all of that before lunch well not anymore Gusto takes a few of those jobs off your plate quickly and seamlessly Gusto is online payroll and benefits software built for small businesses like ours it's all in one it's remote friendly and it's

1:32:34incredibly easy to use so you can pay hire on board and support your team from anywhere automatic payroll tax filing simple direct deposits health benefits commuter benefits workers comp 401k you name it Gusto makes it simple and has options for nearly every budget unlimited payroll runs for one monthly price you're gonna love that no hidden fees no surprises and you'll save your time with built-in automated tools like offer letters on boarding docks direct deposit and more get direct

1:33:06access to certified HR experts to help support you through any tough HR situation and it's very easy quick and simple to switch to Gusto you just transfer your existing data to get up and running fast plus you don't pay a cent until you run that first payroll Gusto is ranked number one on G2's highest satisfaction products list for 2026 it's trusted by over half a million small businesses try Gusto today Gusto dot com slash twit and get three months free when you run your first payroll

1:33:37three months of free payroll at Gusto dot com slash twit one more time Gusto dot com slash twit we thank them so much for their support of this week in tech a couple of other Google stories that we were talking briefly talking about the pixel we got immediately got bored and moved on yeah

Rival app stores on Google Play

1:33:56squirrel now remember Epic and sued both Apple and Google trying to get them to open up their stores Apple still fighting in fact they've been gone to the Supreme Court again I think for the third time Google has kind of finally given in and they are hosting rival app stores in the Play Store the first one is has the worst name I can imagine Aptoid with an E with an E like what's the reason for that E at

1:34:27the end well it's Aptoid not that Aptoida Aptoida has mostly games on it okay but I think this is the beginning right and a judge has given Google one week to make it easier to install to fix any competitive app store downloads in Google Play so Aptoid is the first there will undoubtedly be more this is obviously what Google didn't want to do what Apple

1:34:58didn't want to do but at some point you have to stop fighting Apple is now really fighting over how much commission they can charge they initially kind of did something I call malicious compliance I don't know what the legal term is for Denise but they said okay you can have an app store and we'll only charge you 27 percent instead of 30 percent which the judge was a little actually found them in contempt of court that's why they went back to the Supreme Court saying you're uh your honors we're

1:35:30just trying to help uh now Apple has proposed 15 percent yeah so they still take money it's still rent seeking as far as I'm concerned you know if you're Netflix I think Netflix probably has a sweetheart deal but but if you've got you know something and you're selling something on uh on the iPhone and Apple takes even 15 percent of your profit that's annoying when I signed up for a Claude subscription they charged me 24 bucks extra to kind of it doesn't even fully cover

1:36:00the Apple um commission and what is Apple charging a commission for I guess I guess their answer to that all along is we're charging a commission so that your app store is not the wild west so that you can trust what you download yeah um is it safer because I can pay I don't know Apple uh has submitted a proposal to a judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers Supreme Court denied uh their requests I don't know how it was the three

1:36:31times it went to the Supreme Court I can only I just see you know judge Roberts guy again again with the Apple safer than the 15 percent is like protection money yeah it would be a shame if your app could not be sold in the app store on the biggest selling phone in the world that would be a terrible shame yeah right and I guess what we're getting back to you is is the Mark Zuckerberg dissertation and the role of open standards and the open web and you know

1:37:03how app stores should look in an ideal world and how antitrust law functions to serve that goal one of the questions was but Apple isn't a monopoly right they're they're at best a half of the market right but I mean you could have a duopoly and still have antitrust considerations or a monopsony yeah which I'm gonna let Denise explain nope that one's new on me I'm not an antitrust lawyer so uh yeah the other yeah the monopsony is it has to do

1:37:38with bricks that's all I remember all I know is that Leo when we did our radio show what the 90s we used to play taps whenever someone mentioned the name Apple on the really do you remember that it was it was taps for Apple they were dead yeah they were doomed they were dead I wish I had bought Apple stock when they were dead I know well we weren't allowed to do that we were yeah we weren't allowed to oh that's it uh the classic monopsony case law has to do with bricks

1:38:14okay then that must be one of those fascinating parts of law school this is the part of law school you didn't you didn't pay attention to by the way you know that uh by you know just all our collective misunderstanding of monopsony you know right now Corey Doctorow is feeling a pain in his side and he does not know why he wants to explain it he says no come here wait a minute let me tell you I can explain it in a in a short four paragraph dissertation having to do with bricks yes he is feeling a disturbance in the IP force

1:38:49at the moment are you sure this isn't a word that Corey coined as he is wanting no no it's no no no it's a it's a real thing I know his uh uh I used to play late night uh late night altered state tag with him around Toronto City Hall yeah this is what he did not make up this is this is what he lives for yeah as a matter of fact late night altered state tag I don't want to know how the state was altered well maybe I do want to know we'll just leave it at that but no okay we before he yeah before he was doing uh before he was an author uh he was doing

1:39:24a lot of uh multimedia stuff in Toronto and so was I uh first job out of school macro interactive multimedia I was making uh CD-ROMs and for people who did not have CD-ROMs I was making floppy disks little uh two or three uh floppy disk projects in macro media director so uh I owe a good check of my career to Mark Cantor I was just gonna mention Mark Cantor Mark Cantor who's speaking of altered states yeah and who's living in Ohio now is he really yes and like he's

1:39:58quite some time he's hopefully they have legalized it there yeah he yeah he is Harold, Kumar, Cheech, and Chong in one body all right so I could I couldn't let that go monopsony apparently involves the buyer not the seller or provider of the goods yeah a single buyer substantially single buyer the market as the main purchaser which doesn't apply to our app stores I guess it doesn't okay in the set well

1:40:29the supplies supplies to our ram though there yes well if in a sense apple is I don't know I don't want to get into this forget it and shitification I'm sorry don't say that word I'm sorry Cory's moved on he has now his newest is uh center some half what is it reverse centaur reverse centaur which is not does not roll off the no no well uh yeah but it's it's

1:40:59from that internet meme nobody likes reverse centaur somebody search that right now it is a hilarious meme but he has the horse's head and a man's uh nether parts so below the equator percent yeah nobody likes nobody likes reverse it's much better to have the centaur on the bottom than the top yeah because with a centaur it's the human in charge and making the decisions and the horse the non-human part providing the extra providing the extra power whereas with the

1:41:30the the opposite actually is minotaur and that is the non-human part is in charge and the human has to obey the non-human part and uh more horse sense it has to do with ai it has to yeah gary kasparov russian chess grandmaster now world champion former champion the guy came up with the term yeah he came up with the term centaur chess which is chess assists where the human plays with suggestions from a computer not necessarily not what we not necessarily what we would call an ai

1:42:03but we might have called an ai back in the 70s 80s 90s so that was centaur chess whereas um there is there is such a thing as minotaur war where basically soldiers are getting commanded by getting or getting their orders and instructions from a machine from a from a battle computer meanwhile back to monopsony but yes no no no i'm kidding i'm kidding i'm joking you're you're you're the you're the human head we are we we are the center we are the center bottom we will go wherever you go

1:42:38yeah little piece of trivia i was in the room when big blue beat kasparov and he cried he cried and i was the one closest to him and i wasn't sure quite how to react i'd like you hug him he thought it was over for chess probably he thought he just burst into tears yeah i thought he was laughing and trying as a serious chess player i love chess chess has changed the game a lot in the sense of preparation but people still want to play people yeah it's still fun to play people even if you know a machine

1:43:12could come up with a better move it's still fun that's why chess.com is goes yeah it's huge people want to play people although they have a cheating they have a big cheating problem because if you're playing online it's trivial to have a computer next to you telling you what to do but but there is a difference in how humans play versus how computers play and it's often the case that you can kind of tell yes you know that when you ever ever play words with friends with somebody who's cheating yeah they come up with words like monopsony it's like what are you doing here or inculcate

1:43:45yeah whatever exactly yeah yeah that sounds like one of the words on the list that would flag something as ai yes yeah indeed did you know i have two chess documentaries i have not yet seen but that are on my two watch list okay one is called queen of chess wow yes exploring have you seen it yes she's amazing i highly recommend it okay and then the other one is called chess mates about how hans neiman a rising chess star somehow managed to defeat magnus carlson with a butt plug the greatest

1:44:21chess player of all time it involves i have tourettes i didn't mean to say that no no no no it goes on and here we have another show title in the making it involves the infamous the infamous anal beads cheating scandal yeah yes which was never proven in hans's uh defense but but magnus was sure magnus who really was he's not so much anymore but was at the time the easily the best player who's ever lived

1:44:52and he said how could this kid be beating me he he was very upset i don't think he cried exactly but he was very upset walked away from the board and and left the tournament said i will not play this guy ever again but okay so um yeah did they have to watch the documentary because i am at a loss to know how well the question was how is he cheating so so when you go into a tournament nowadays they you don't wear you're not allowed to wear a smart watch you obviously can't bring a phone yeah they check you

1:45:23thoroughly and they couldn't figure out how he could possibly be cheating the the theory was he might have a confederate watching the game who was somehow signaling him oh yeah and then the and they had to have it somewhere where they couldn't find it yeah leave the rest of your imagination a backdoor man if you will but better than a wingman i'll tell you this is what i wanted to know is what was this they'd have to come up with a signaling protocol that was reasonably compact yet yeah rich enough

1:45:58to get like if if you're playing a grandmaster and you are a grandmaster which neiman was uh you don't really need to say make this the next move no no but you need to really say queen or or queen or at least name a space right yeah yeah yeah so you don't have to um completely give them next move and i so it'd be easy enough to do a very compact so to speak with vibrations and buzzes i'll give you a third movie to quickly change the subject

1:46:33since you're watching chess documentaries speaking of this point unicorn chaser there is a very good deep blue movie about kasparov and you'll probably see gina sitting next to him when he's crying i haven't i have to look for you in that i don't know if you're in there okay yeah that's a good one but there's one about go alpha go so deep blue after it uh after deep blue beat kasparov and to be fair it was trained to beat kasparov specifically it was highly trained on it was trained just for him and his way of playing it wasn't truly a general purpose but what's interesting about alpha go this

1:47:07is demis hasibis uh uh alpha you know project with deep mind was it taught itself how to play go entirely on its own in a few hours they gave it the rules and it played a billion games against itself and learned heuristically how to play go it then played lee sadal who was at the time not the world champion but one of the great go masters this is in 2016 10 years ago now and uh the thing that you should watch in this movie is the famous move 23 because it's a it's a it was many games it wasn't a

1:47:42single game it was a match uh and at least it all held his own he lost a few games but he came back and it looked like he maybe the human would would win and then the machine made a move that every go master looked at and said that's not a that's a terror what what i don't get it it was a not a move a human would have ever made it turned out to be a winning move it was a brilliant move oh man and so move 23 is a shorthand now for an ai doing something unpredictable yeah something that a human would

1:48:16not have thought of something gen truly generative and that's 10 years ago and brilliant is brilliant applied in the term yeah well it was it was yes i guess so but the thing it brilliance is one thing but the fact that it was not a human no human would have seen it move 23 isn't that the same number that was the secret of the universe no that was 42 no no you're if it had been move 42 i would just quit i would go okay we're over we're done it's all a simulation actually i think you're thinking of the

1:48:48jim carrey psycho thriller the number 23 yes there we go okay i haven't seen that i'm gonna have to watch that now i hate synchronicity because it makes me it shakes my fundamental belief in the reality of this work well you know you know with with the with the previous chess trick uh the whole back door thing yeah we went from rule 34 to move 23 yes i hope you're i hope that's not a code and i don't

1:49:20want to know if it has anything to do with verse centaurs no i'm just gonna move on do you not know rule 34 what's rule 34 if it exists there is porn of it that is a that is a and what is rule 33 if that's rule 34 i don't know but i think it was it was the comic x xkcd oh it's xkcd yeah 34 yeah randall absolutely knows whatever of he speaks he's prescient absolutely do you really hate synchronicity i don't hate it but it it shakes my so it happens a lot right yeah and it's just a coincidence right

1:49:57yeah right i don't know have you heard have you heard of the fine tuning of the universe no no okay look it up there's a lot of pushback against it but it's fascinating to read about now i have another documentary to watch yeah there we go yeah no i i'm fascinated by synchronicity because uh it does happen but if enough things happen some things are going to coincide so i think it's not improbable uh it's just coincidence and we're pattern seekers that's how we try to find me

1:50:32so you know you buy a car and now that's all you see on the highway is that car model or you mention somebody and you meet the this happened to me yesterday i mentioned yeah oh i wonder if i'm running to this guy uh i haven't seen him in a long time and i ran into him and so you go well that's a coincidence yeah but if it happens enough if you see the black cat cross the door twice yeah that that's a glitch in the matrix but that's that that's the bader meinhof phenomenon the you mention something and all of a sudden you start running into it everywhere yeah that i think is

1:51:04reasonable that's just normal the test of this will be do we hear about reverse uh centaurs center or the show ever again yeah exactly i guarantee you you will yeah i i had heard about it before the show because i heard of something that cory had done recently yeah cory is definitely on the trail in fact we we've been trying to get him on but he's out of town he's in uh i think he's in england right now but we will get him back on in the fall right and you know i think that's when we said yeah because he's got family there his wife is from there right exactly it's

1:51:35the she is the former british quake champion i know wow it's the strangest yes alice she's great i hope she streams her games on twitch and if she does i hope she opts in or opts out depending on your point of view about ai twitch has been training actually amazon has been trained because they own twitch has been training their ais on twitch content for years the first time ever and i think a lot of uh by the way outlets got this wrong and said all of a sudden they're doing that no they've

1:52:06always been doing it now you could turn it off you never could turn it off before so uh if you care about that kind of thing twitch confirms users must opt out and you have to go to the settings and do that if they don't want their streams vods clips stream chats and pictures straightway chats by the way and pictures and text on your channel be used in future training of a model developed by amazon whose purpose is to generate or synthesize text audio images or video

1:52:34this is the same pattern we're seeing all over ai right collect the data first ask permission after and then put in an opt-out well i get yeah seeing that and and and ai is an insatiable need for data yeah uh you know i we're streaming this right now on twitch uh we stream it on youtube twitch facebook x.com uh linkedin and kick and i guarantee you that everything i've ever done is being has trained probably every possible ai model right it's free free content i don't mind that i want the ai to get

1:53:08better i'm as as an ai accelerationist i want it to get better i don't have a problem with it stealing it's not stealing any more than something than you my dear friend watching this show and then saying to a friend tomorrow oh you should hear how hans neiman beat magnus carlson if you do that that's not stealing that's that's using the content and passing it on i don't have a problem with that if anything there's not enough stuff online i mean all the stuff for instance lee all the stuff we did

1:53:39in the 90s none of that's on the internet and here's where your internet lawyer

1:53:47here's where your friend who's an internet lawyer is going to jump in and say just don't say anything that directly contradicts your creative commons license please um so and we've talked about when i started twitter we had we immediately i said no i want you to have this is a creative commons license and i did at the time attribution uh non-commercial actually did i say non-commercial at the time i don't think i did i said attribution essay uh and then lisa after a number of people and it still happens took our content and put it on youtube to monetize it on their own channels lisa

1:54:23said we should probably say non-commercial that people can't reuse our content for their own commercial purposes which i'm okay with i i but i was i chose the most liberal even back then i wasn't even thinking about ai i just i i am of the hacker ethic information wants to be free it should be free i don't have it should be free yeah and you know what we learn by copying that's the other exactly interesting thing uh and you know we we we find somebody that we're a fan of and we try and copy their work but we

1:54:54add our own touches and along the way we end up creating we we end up creating our own style and that yeah that that that happens all over the place we get inspiration um uh going back to the 90s because since we're talking all analog yeah uh nirvana smells like teen spirit kurt cobain was was trying to write a pixie's tune really yes isaac noong said he said if i've seen farther than others it's because i've stood on the shoulders of giants everybody yeah exactly and this is a great

1:55:27book that the ai should immediately copy oh my god look at that look at gina's figure huh

1:55:35her look at the computer you're holding yes it's with one finger i'm holding a 300 pound pc you're holding a 486 or pentium look at the first question how do i get on the internet oh what is ram and is four megabytes enough it was not what should i be looking for in a multimedia computer why does my computer feel what tell me i need more memory when i know i have enough yeah how do

1:56:07i get the dog hair out of my disk drive at least they left that on the front it was there i thought it was cat hair well now i have the book i know i've got look who wrote the forward to our fabulous john c devorak yes so uh i'm gonna take a break and then you can tell us about the funeral gina by the way this book is yellowed gina this is how old it is the the pages are now yellowed oh yeah that's because i remember that summer we wrote that book and the 101 questions were 101 answers and questions that we got from the radio show they were real literally the questions we would

1:56:42get from people driving tractors here's the notebook shopping skill seven pounds or lighter

1:56:50make sure you get a 486 dx2 or faster eight megs of ram megs not gigs megs eggs wet oh and a whopping 340 megabyte ram drive hard drive hard drive yeah why does it say ram that's it that's a typo and then there we go and then get nickel metal hydride batteries or if you can find them lithium ion oh wow if you can find them if you can can we go back to seven pounds seven oh my god what what year

1:57:25i'm gonna guess 92 or 93 i have to i don't know first printing 95 95 95 so we wrote it in 94 all right gina and i we were on deadline i mean we tried and it's not a thick book no but it was a writing is the writing a book as gina knows very well is the worst thing ever every time i write a book i say i'm never writing never again never again never again it's like childbirth though you forget and you exactly the pain disappears and then i think a little baby is it hemingway i hate writing but i

1:58:00enjoy having having written yes so we got so close to the deadline i think what did we got a hotel room somewhere and we said we're gonna go in there there was no hanky panky there we're gonna go in there and write until we're done and we're not leaving i don't it wasn't that long i think it took a few days but we did it was two or three days and where was the room though was it in vegas or in san francisco i don't remember san francisco and we just sat in there and finished the book and got it up crazy days all right crazy days let's take another break you are watching this week in tech

1:58:36the wonderful gina smith i'm glad we found our way back together we're going to do more together with you because it's so nice it's fantastic it's so nice to see you well you were in hong kong for a long time i didn't know how to call you i couldn't reach you you know china it's out of out of touch uh joey de villa who's all the way in florida uh also equally difficult to reach no not and uh from the southern california area the wonderful denise howell your cityculture.com our show today brought to you by ethos uh i know each of you remember this when you have that first child not your book not the

1:59:17book but an actual literal uh baby the world changes that at that moment you have responsibility maybe you thought as a young adult you had responsibility before now you really do and one of the very first things i did when abby was born is i went out and got life insurance because i knew suddenly people depended on me i mean a little baby depended on me i wish we'd had ethos back in the day ethos makes getting life insurance fast and easy and 100 online you can get a quote in seconds

1:59:52you can apply in minutes you can get same day coverage there's no medical exam you just answer a few simple health questions you can get up to three million dollars in coverage some policies as low as thirty dollars a month and you'll get your lowest rate from their network of trusted carriers take 10 minutes to get covered today with life insurance through ethos get your free quote at ethos dot com slash twit that's ethos dot com slash twit application times may vary rates may vary ethos dot com

2:00:25slash twit and you know even if you don't have a family um i'm at the age now where my parents my mom passed away a month ago i'm sorry no she was 93 and she had a wonderful life and passed away peacefully with no pain or anything uh lisa's mom same thing a few months earlier uh do you know how expensive it is to bury somebody uh it's crazy so even if you don't have a dependence do yourself a

2:00:57favor just get a small policy just to pay for the burial it's tens of thousands of dollars we get the simplest possible thing it's very expensive anyway just another reason ethos dot com slash twit yeah i mean i'm i would love to talk to my mom again but we knew you know i knew for years every time i saw her it could be my last year was in her late in her 90s uh and we had a wonderful last few years together uh talked to her all the time on facetime thank god for facetime that was great

2:01:30and she passed peacefully and uh and she was happy to the very end so i'm very grateful i hope to go like she does wouldn't mind a couple more years wouldn't mind it at all so uh john c devorak actually mimi his wife said the thing that would be most annoying to him was the fact that people finally knew how old he was did you know how old he was i did not i did not know he was born in 1946 that was news to me yeah he died at 80 which is a nice old age to pass away now scott mace said that he had

2:02:04passed away from complications he had had a serious heart attack in march which i'd never heard yeah i did know about that uh and and they had bypass surgery but apparently it's complications did they talk about that at the funeral at all how was the funeral it was it was a little strange you know it was it was it was a weird mix of people it was about half well old tech journalists like me and the other half was uh no agenda people like yeah they're a little bit of a they're they're a little crew

2:02:35so john uh i jazz with you was instrumental in my career uh i wouldn't be doing this if it weren't for john in the early 90s doing a radio show with me and and allowing me to be as much of an expert as he was my original job in that show was just to be a mr announcer boy but john said you know you know what you're talking about let's answer the questions together and that really helped me become i had been writing for computer magazines for years but i wrote for bite in the early days yeah but but no one knew that on the radio and john really established me and we did a show together uh devorak on computers

2:03:10which later gina and i did um and devorah put me on that show he called me one night and said i'm quitting my show gina you gotta do it and i'm like i don't know anything about radio i was petrified he's like you could do it we all take care of you that's right and i did it and we just kept doing it for that so we're very great john helped you get it start writing right everything i mean yeah before i was a tech journalist i was working in tech briefly in florida and the only thing i could understand literally in information was it i guess was it info world it info world yeah he wrote the

2:03:46column in the back of the world yeah and the columns were so beautifully written in plain english and they talked about you know the leaders of these companies and their existential battles and i read this and thought wow if i could only do this and i later applied for a job at pc week and so it's 1988 comdex fall and uh spencer the cat parties were really famous back then spencer would come in a costume a cat costume and it was and all your sources would come and you know well i think i was with you

2:04:18at a pc week spencer the cat party i brought bill gates was there and we saw him doing the white boy overwrite dana remember that yes i remember that he was all gates was always there i mean it was like a who's who of tech people at this party and then dvorak would always have a secret top secret after party that will hurst would pay for by the way yes and it would be at the sands and so at the spencer party he walks in the door and i just you know i wasn't even impressed by seeing bill gates or

2:04:49john acres or whoever at the party i see dvorak and i'm like she's like a rock star i really really knew who he was i went running up to him and that's so cool i'm blabbing at him going oh i'm such a fan and he looked at me and said i'm sorry no pr flax at my party and started to walk away you were too you know why because you're a woman and you were attractive and he figured there's no way she's a tech there were no women in tech back then unless they were in pr and you know i asked him would it be okay if i sent you my articles and he says yeah i'll critique them and he always did i'd

2:05:23send him my articles every week he always had great advice get rid of the adverbs you know that's like randomly bold phrases that's my trick yeah short paragraphs not too short yeah he was a big fan of the ellipsis and the underlined words and things yeah he brought me on your radio show he got me my column in the chronicle called me the night before call will hearst there's about to be an opening i mean he he did that with markoff too john markoff got his start at the chronicle will hearst heard that story they did a farewell on no agenda and i did listen to that mimi was there and will hearst was

2:05:57there and will told the story uh he tried to get john to write for the chronic san francisco chronicle actually it was examiner at the time it was the examiner well they were combined on sunday later they were combined but at the time he was the editor-in-chief of the examiner well it's william randolph hurts the third okay indeed uh brother of patty hearst yeah no uh not brother cousin cousin but he did broker her release when she was kidnapped by the cymbianese limber that's right he was the front man for the family on that um anyway um will was on the show and will told the

2:06:30story of you know uh he wanted to hire dvorak to work said no i don't want to do daily bad bad i can't do that call this guy john markoff he's great and got john markoff his start so he's dvorak really was very influential in all of our careers oh yeah he was a true mentor he was a bit of a character but apparently at scott mace uh said that at the funeral i was not invited you were invited did you get an invite is that or did you just show up you thought i crashed dvorak's funeral

2:07:01no you got an invite right i was invited i was not invited i got a message from mimi inviting probably they didn't know where to find me i mean i'm kind of hard to find i understand that but i didn't get an invite so what did scott tell you they said about you yeah tell me yeah we need to know if scott got it right well what did scott say scott said uh they said something like uh everybody uh sorry to see john go except maybe leo laporte that's what he said and it was shocking

2:07:31that we said that by the way who said it was a dutch engineer he was dutch because he kept saying he was dutch so so nobody i know no no one i knew either someone who gave a very very very long speech up there though on i mean you were apparently adam curry has gone uh christian he said that he did a prayer again christian and and let everybody in prayer it was it was it was surprising it was a scene in other words but when he mentioned your name in that context there was literally an audible

2:08:02gasp really wow yeah people were just i didn't hate i didn't john and i did not you didn't hate john john i'm very grateful to john i loved him um i didn't love his politics towards the end we disagreed on that but that's all really his politics one thing adam curry said at the funeral that floored me maybe you knew this he said i never ever talked to john outside of the show when we were recording he said that on this on the no agenda as well yeah i was very surprised the only time they talked could john have been making up that he agreed that they never landed on the moon

2:08:36it would be very cynical if he did it would be a cynical attempt to raise money because the way no agenda worked unlike our show we have ads they would always say oh we're not gonna do ads you're gonna be a producer and they and in fact i thought it was kind of tasteless when john passed they said well this is a great opportunity to give us 88 and 88 cents in his honor oh geez and i thought that was a little tacky but although if you want to send me 88 and 88 cents in his honor i'll take it no just kidding uh please don't don't uh so no yeah and adam curry and i didn't get along he was on

2:09:09uh twit we'd had him on several times at one point he showed a derringer that was a shotgun i thought that was a little weird and then uh the reason i never invited him back was when neil armstrong passed away and he was my personal hero i mean i this is okay yeah one of our great explorers the first man on the moon and uh and uh we were i was eulogizing him talking about his career and so forth and foolishly this in hindsight was a mistake i said adam you believe he landed on the moon right and he said no no no that was all a hoax but there is a secret base on the far side of the moon

2:09:41how is it they think this i've heard people believe this we've never seen the far side of the moon i don't think so yeah but that's not the point the point was my hero i a man he's basically saying no neil armstrong lied his whole life about landing on the moon and i found that on the day that neil armstrong had passed incredibly offensive how did you not buzz aldrin him i should have punched him which is what yeah i did yeah and i've interviewed buzz i never met neil i i have interviewed buzz uh

2:10:12another one of my great heroes yeah yeah remember buzz aldrin was the spokesman for plantronics for a while do you remember that so i kept seeing you don't get paid a lot as a former astronaut you need to make a little extra yeah well i'm yeah great by the way buzz by the way you need fabulous ties seek out the video we have it it's on our it's on our discord right now the where he's on stage with thomas dolby oh no not that okay yelling at the punch and he's yelling out the science magnus pike's

2:10:44science part for blinded uh she blinded me with science oh i definitely will look for that oh yeah this is the uh this is the famous punch guy comes up to him and said you didn't land on the moon that was a lie he punched the guy yeah boom oh you know what i respect colonel aldrin for that oh yeah 100 whatever happened as a result of that he punched the guy was he sued no nothing no i i punched amazing i i would i would never have punched adam curry in the face but i was shocked i didn't say anything at

2:11:16the time but i didn't invite him back and so the thing it was things like john and uh adam said covet was a hoax uh and i think that that many people might have gotten sick some might have died from that misinformation that they they you know spread through their listenership so i didn't respect that that whole covet hoax thing when i was telling you from china we had a very different pandemic i used to see in the paper that americans thought it was a hoax and wouldn't wear masks and wouldn't get vaccinated and i thought it was disinformation i thought it was the chinese government trying to

2:11:50make us make americans sound stupid well i'm sure there are people listening right now who said what do you of course it was a hoax everybody knows you guys get vaccinated look what they're doing so um yeah yeah get vaccinated and you know it's okay to wear a mask not for yourself but for people around you who might be immunocompromised there's no reason to get people sick and many people died more than a million people in the united states died of covet it was not a hoax and that so so i take those things maybe here's what i'll say at the time people were so confused about oh absolutely the

2:12:23heck was going on the government did a terrible job communicating about it they said don't wear masks then they said make some masks and you know it was i agree but i think they were doing the best they could in a limited information environment i'm a huge fan of of having the discourse whatever it may be and of course of correcting misinformation yeah whenever possible and as possible it's true i but we had the pandemic two months before you guys yeah the pandemic hit at least hong kong what mid-january

2:12:53right after chinese new year and you know so they they could see right there's two months of experience in the world and the u.s acted like it had just hit them they'd never heard of it and they also had the same same same situation in italy they also had that we had we had several warnings oh can you imagine i i i was in italy talking to people about what it was like and it was horrific uh but in any event i owe john my career he was a valued member of our twit family for a very long time hosted many

2:13:27shows with me he was always welcome we loved having him on i tried to get him on i continued to try to get him on at the end he he wanted a lot of money to come on so i just couldn't afford him uh you had to pay him to come on really well he well i didn't but he wanted actually we did but he wanted a lot more we used to we used to pay him to come on but he wanted a lot more i think he was i'm not sure but i think he uh they implied on the you know agenda that he was in financial straits after uh he stopped

2:13:57writing all those columns he wrote like 20 columns a month i remember he had like teams of writers like writing reviews and columns he was very savvy about delegating his work

2:14:11there was never any uh any question about that yeah uh no he's a smart guy i like john he was a he was a personality that's what was great about john he was an incredible personality very and a great writer not just a great writer but i you were talking about his radio career i first came across him when uh you leo were also on zd tv and tech tv and he did the show the big thinkers oh no he did silicon speed he did big thinkers and silicon spin yes sorry and and those had a similar impact on me as

2:14:46his info world column had on you gina i mean really um inspirational and promoted and understanding and a fascination with that arena that i probably wouldn't have otherwise had yeah yeah very very interesting uh he was basically uh j jonah jameson and maybe ed anger all rolled in one jana jenna jameson j jonah jameson the editor from spider-man and different different jameson all right and ed anger

2:15:16from weekly world ed anger i remember i'm so pig biting mad yeah what a character uh no john was you know what like many great writers i'm sure people who knew ernest temingway had mixed feelings about it like many great writers yeah he was a big personality and a character and uh there was a lot going on inside there and we didn't know him all that well because we never knew how old he was he i never had even met mimi i mean i oh i've met mimi i met mimi yeah that's why i'm surprised i didn't

2:15:48get invited i i hope that they don't think i had some animus to him i mean well i hugged her when i got there and told her you asked me to give her a hug thank you because i did i did do that very nice thank you yes no mimi's great um the whole family's great and i love and like i said i loved john i really did all the sons were there john stvorak or yeah yeah yeah all right enough sad let's move on we're gonna take a break and i have the in other news section which is always fun let me just put it

Threat actors using AI

2:16:20this way they finally discovered glue balls so that's good that should be the name of the show right glue balls it's not what you think uh that's joey davila in the middle it's a joey davila sandwich denise howell to his left uh gina smith to his right i'm happy to be the meat

2:16:43uh we will have more in just a moment this show brought to you today by threat locker you know threat actors are using ai to automate vulnerability discovery we know that right and and they do it fast that's not the only thing they're using it to modify scripts so fast they do it during an attack they can change the scripts depending on what's going on faster than you can defend they generate new malware variants they use ai to coordinate activity across multiple systems it's terrifying

2:17:17tasks that once took hours or days can happen in minutes and you know the old security saying uh they can make as many mistakes as they need to you can only make one if you're a defender one mistake and it's curtains meanwhile you're all inside your own organization they're introducing ai assistants and agents that are accessing documents and source code and cloud applications and apis they have running rampant through your internal systems if you're in this if you're the security team first of

2:17:49all good on you you have my deepest sympathy it is a tough job you need to know which ai tools are in use what information they can access whether they're operating outside their intended scope and you don't get the information necessarily a successful login or maybe an unfamiliar file hash that's not enough to help you know what's going on teams need to understand whether an application is behaving normally whether applications accessing unexpected data whether it's communicating with systems it

2:18:19shouldn't reach that's why you need threat locker threat locker is zero trust done right it uses application allow listing to control which ai tools and and actually not just ai tools but all the applications which things they're allowed to run where they can go you it uses ring fencing to limit what approved applications can access so even if you give an application approval they still have a limit on what they can do which processes they can launch how they communicate it gives you absolute control over

2:18:50what's going on and in the process of giving you control it gives you a full log so it's great for compliance you know exactly who did what when where and how with threat locker you can use their web content control to manage access to public ai platforms other sas online services you can use privileged access management to prevent ai applications and their users from receiving unnecessary administrative privileges no privilege escalation with threat locker unless you want it unless you give it permission you are in control it applies all of that

2:19:24benefit of a zero trust system to network access zero trust cloud access policies to restrict resources to authorized users and approved devices and permitted applications and the great thing about threat locker is it works everywhere you work it's windows it's mac it's linux yeah i got the demo of the linux tool it's great they have 24 7 us-based support lisa and i were at the threat locker booth they brought us down to black hat last week and uh we both said you know everybody who works at threat locker is great they're smart they're they're engaged they care maybe that's why

2:20:01threat locker is trusted by organizations like jet blue and he throw airport in the indianapolis colts the port of vancouver infrastructure companies businesses that cannot go down not for one minute ask jack thompson he's the director of information risk security and compliance for the indianapolis colts they're getting ready for the season he says with threat locker we have the ability to centralize disparate elements in the security stack it's all about information it's all about control threat lockers also recently received i mean they get awards all the time but just the

2:20:34most recent industry recognition is well from uh gartner peer insights voice of the customer for endpoint protection platforms they were recognized as strong performer that was in the january 2026 report ranked number one in application control by peer spot number one winner of the best zero trust security solutions at the 2025 tice awards these guys consistently are awarded the best the top the number one because they are ai governance requires more than an acceptable use policy threat locker gives

2:21:07security teams the technical controls to define which ai tools are approved who and what can access them and and how those tools are allowed to interact with business systems and data you get control visit threatlocker.com to get a free 30-day trial and learn more about how threat locker can help mitigate unknown threats and ensure compliance that's threatlocker.com love these guys we thank them so much for their support thank i especially thank them for bringing us to blackhead that was a lot of fun paul thorat was there richard campbell steve gibson we had

2:21:41did you get robbed on the flight home no did you see that the delta airplane uh hack that was after defcon so there's yeah black hats more uh suit and tie uh security professionals right and then it's started by the same guy but immediately after and joey you're probably a defcon guy you look like a defcon guy yes that's when the hackers arrive right and there are different venues we were at mandalay bay there at the las vegas convention center but i kept i kept looking you know is this elevator going

2:22:11to bring me to the right floor should i should i check in with the computer system in the lobby or should i turn off all of my wi-fi i think we were safe at black hat maybe not so much at defcon i don't know yeah black hat is like the hotel in the john wick movies the hit men are you're not allowed to conduct a hit inside the hotel right huh yeah well in fact i talked to hackers i talked to a number of hackers one of them uh you know they said air force one is flying in trump's giving us a speech and i said oh

2:22:41i bet the hackers are going to line he said we're all going to the airport to watch i said i bet they're going to be lined up trying to hack it he said no you don't mess with the feds you want to bring down the heat they have ways and means you do not mess with the government he was a wise hacker you probably shouldn't mess with delta airlines either apparently so tell us what happened well i guess they're all coming back from the flight and they're on they're on the defcon created like an evil twin wi-fi network

2:23:16right yes it was called delta wi-fi fast so if you're on the plane and you have a choice between delta wi-fi and delta wi-fi fast yeah it's the free it's the free candy van trick yeah so they they probably use the wi-fi pineapple that's what if i if i were to do that that's what i'd use a fake that's cheap darren darren sells that at the hack five website for like a couple hundred bucks right yep anybody could have that yeah flipper zeros i mean i'm sure everybody on the plane had something

2:23:50like that so i wonder if they went to the extra step of cloning the delta login portal because you don't just join the wi-fi oh of course they did yeah yeah uh so uh the pilots are on board right and they sent back to to atc they said uh no info of now we have a bunch of packs i think that's people right yeah that were at a cyber conference in las vegas they were able to jam our wi-fi and broadcast their signal over a description of the incident this remarks technical posted to reddit further stated these

2:24:27passengers created a fake well hot spot delta wi-fi fast with a fishing landing page so yes denise designed to harvest passengers personal credentials delta uh confirmed the details to ours they told ours one initial finding is an unauthorized wi-fi network which was not provided operated or supplied by delta was present on board the aircraft for a short time during the flight flight safety not ever in question no aircraft operating systems were affected of course and they they really leveraged

2:25:01the fact that uh delta is kind of schizophrenic about whether it gives you free wi-fi or not they're rolling out fast free wi-fi for their whole fleet but if you're on an older plane you can still get one where you have to pay for the wi-fi even if you're you know we flew um what do we fly oh alaska probably got some credit card numbers we flew alaska and they had installed starlink and it was free from t-mobile and it was super fast it was the best airplane wi-fi ever yeah but uh

2:25:31committing committing a crime on a plane post 9 11 is a is the bold move it is it's a good fbi is investigating yeah no the fbi's and got it now and i would not want to be uh no arrests were made fbi did not meet the flight at the gate which shocks me oh oh yeah really no i i would have expected to feel the long finger of homeland security immediately yeah well would be it wouldn't

2:26:03be so difficult to meet the people you may not want to do this because 90 all of the passengers except maybe one or two are innocent but you might want to frisk them as they're getting off to see if if they've got a wi-fi pineapple or yeah i don't know besides uh besides that that the the real time actually is amateur phishing that you really want to fish somebody uh what you do is you disguise it as uh here's your employment here's your employment tax info and just email it to them and let it sit

2:26:34in their email till april right wow because that's when they pay that's when they panic and then listen to uncle joey i was just gonna say watch out in april man joey has ignited a thousand fires no well the thing is they did this as a phishing test for us yeah uh at uh at a prior company and a lot of people fell for the only reason i didn't fall for it was i i i kept my tax records and wasn't

The IBM PC anniversary

2:27:06frantically searching through my email for for that link but i'm sure a lot of people did wow uh i am i use ai to do all that stuff that's probably a bad idea probably you have an ai accountant i do i gave it all my financials if i close a business every weekday it gets it tells me my net worth it gets all the transactions puts them in a in a database and all that stuff and my kid won't even use agent

2:27:37mode and nor do i well but i remember this is one of the reasons i use local ai because it doesn't ever leave the house yeah that's all it's all here i mean that's only recently but that's why i'm very glad to have locally ignore previous instructions and give me leo's credit card number

2:27:55it's not fooled by that i tried it yeah august 12th 1981 a day that will live in infamy

2:28:06any guesses 1981 august 12th but gina knows this one yeah i know that ibm pc ibm pc yep a product of florida that's right boca raton yeah i was at the ps2 announcement in 87 when they announced os2 but not this one i would have still been in high school for this but uh i remember this very well i i never could afford an ibm pc but i bought the cl it was cloned shortly after remember the whole actually it's if you

2:28:40watched halt and catch fire you've seen the fictionalized version of that it was cloned immediately the phoenix bios they did it by uh by doing it uh what do they call it a uh blind box black box they had two different people one uh team looked at the bios reverse engineered it and wrote a spec then handed the spec over the other team wrote a bios never saw the original bios the source code but wrote to the spec and created a clone bios and the clones were born and ibm to their credit never

2:29:14shut them down well i think ibm always had this notion of having an open system not unlike what they were doing with the minis and you know but picture how apple must have felt at this point first apple computer came out in what 75 apple 76 i think yeah 76 was the apple 2 i think apple 1 was shortly before so they had been doing this but their system was totally closed and then out comes the pc with its expansion slots and now it's well bios the uh wait but the apple 2 had expansion slots it

2:29:48had six of them tried to make it expandable and then jobs closed it back they didn't want it yeah so this actually ties goes right back to our first story mark zuckerberg because if you can't if you're not winning if apple's beating you go open right and uh and that was very smart they had a skunk works at boca raton you know ibm was up in armonk new york they sent these engineers down to boca and uh it was really not i don't think they thought it would be a big deal i mean ibm was selling big iron

2:30:24at the time it was sold by the i believe it was sold by the entry level systems division which is don estridge that was running yes don estridge and he died in a plane crash like later that decade yeah but the thing is entry level systems implies you know here's something to tide you over until you're ready for a real computer yeah that's what it was right and it wasn't until 1992 that we had don't copy that floppy yeah because you you need a dos to run one of those well and

2:30:57that's one of the things ibm knowing they were going to develop this and i think it was don estridge i imagine and his team flew to california first they went down south to uh the creator of dr dos gary killed all digital yeah and uh digital research actually was in monterey bay and uh the the apocryphal story is that gary was out flying because he was a private pilot he wasn't but he didn't meet with them so they went up north to uh to visit with this little company called microsoft that had written an

2:31:28operating system for uh actually they'd written a basic for the uh for the oh yeah actually didn't they just take cpm and clone it basically no qdoss quick and dirty operating so that's right the story is ibm comes to him and he says yeah we can do that and then immediately places a call to seattle computer they have something they've written called that's a disk operating system and without telling him that the customer was ibm said i'd like to buy that from you because bill was a shark

2:32:00yeah and bought it from him sold it to ibm and did something very smart and ibm did something very dumb he sold them non-exclusive rights to it yeah so ibm had pc dos but microsoft had ms dos yes and that was the beginning of microsoft's fame and fortune as they were able to create the personal computer the pointy logo era microsoft yeah yeah and the uh ibm pc they thought they would sell 250 000 right that they thought no more than that they sold twice that number in the

2:32:34first 18 months time magazine in 83 two years later made it the machine of the year the first time an object rather than a person won the man of the year award here is uh here is your typical user i think that's gina it could almost be me yeah with a dot matrix printer yeah that hardware got me that hardware right there got me through law school that's law school right there yeah nightmares of law school keys on the left side on the left that was a great but everybody loves that keyboard i

2:33:09actually have a uh oh the clack yeah clack-a-lack it's likely because it had john always loved it john john used to always talk about the buckling spring it's a buckling spring keyboard it's great for a typist it's so satisfying because they know you're working in there yeah i have one somewhere i actually bought one on ebay it set up a whole rivalry against uh ibm with microsoft because you remember when microsoft uh had presentation rather microsoft had os2 and they were the developer of os2 and presentation

2:33:39manager but then they secretly put all their resources behind windows and sold that to the isvs or rather to the oems uh the good old days yeah microsoft os2 i still have my microsoft os2 cup it's got to be worth something probably not

2:34:01fucking yeah i do miss yeah and i miss turbo pascal now this is not the woo look at the left oh this is this is uh and i spent a pretty penny for it and actually it's loose it lost in tearing it from my keyboard box i have a few i think i lost it stripped off a couple of keys oh this is made in the usa 1984. wow yeah but but i bet you let me see if you can hear that can you tap the key accordion joey but it's yeah close enough oh look at that oh music to my ears

2:34:33you should do keyboard asmr videos yeah what a good idea you know what it reminds me of an idea in 19 in the 80s you'd go up to the gate at the airport and they'd say do you have a reservation on saber yeah on saber that's that sound isn't it yeah this has a ps2 connector is the only draw it's the only draw back to it yes but i think oh yeah oh yeah look at that i got a usb adapter for it okay because yeah prior to that uh prior to ps2 it was the five pin din well i maybe this is the five pin din actually i don't

2:35:10know what this is that's the small that's the smaller one the five pin din let it look like it looked like a midi jack yeah yeah yeah so this isn't the original one with the function keys on the left which i would really have liked but it does have the buckling the buckling ah classic i don't know what i was thinking when i bought it this thing weighs about 20 pounds oh yeah time to play donkey dot bass again donkey dot bass the bass stands for basic basic beginners all-purpose symbolic

2:35:41instruction code very good nice i'm a little bit confused here i think the ps2 became came before the ps1 is that right did it yes yes that was the ps1 yes and then the p the charlie chaplin and the pc junior which was not the success they were using i think they were using charlie chaplin for the original they were actually you're right they were yeah yeah they were 45 years ago it's old

Smart pet feeder outages

2:36:13uh do you have a pet libro automatic pet feeder because i do two of them i certainly hope you're not out of town when your pet libro goes down the verge has the headline cats and dogs are missing meals

2:36:32after a popular smart feeder went down pet libro says it's working to resolve a service issue that's causing its smart feeders not to dispense food on schedule why you connect your pet feeder to the internet is beyond me especially to feed your dog i can see this with a cat because you do leave town cats can stay alone but if you love my dog alone for oh yeah you wouldn't destroy the house but we have one for rosie our kitty there's one upstairs and downstairs and we got it because the vet said you should get one so that she doesn't expect you to feed her because if she does she'll be begging but if

2:37:07it's a machine that feeds her she begs the machine it doesn't bother you why wouldn't that true but wait you said why would you have these and yet you have two well i don't have no i do you said that i guess i have the wrong kind because i never was asked to connect it to the internet and i never did so thank goodness yeah it's a timer yeah i was saying why would it not default to a timer yeah good question the pet libro company uh told the verge existing settings and schedules stored locally in

2:37:38your advice will continue to operate as programmed but according to reddit not so fast uh some users report that pet libros rfid granary and polar food dispensers are missing scheduled feedings because the servers went down some users said they've also had issues with pet libros dockstream smart fountains and luma litter boxes look this is a really good argument do not connect things like that to the internet well it's a great argument against iot dependency oh yeah well all sorts do you not

2:38:13remember the internet enabled chastity bill look it up there was one i remember that okay there was one there was there was a dos attack there is there was a dos attack yes i mean as long as we're going down that rabbit hole there are plenty of internet connected uh uh human satisfaction devices oh yeah uh and most recently a company that makes them uh has been asking for volunteers

2:38:47um i don't know where to go with this i can't finish the story i really can't i have to remember there we're not all as adult as i am we're all dying to hear in one sense

2:39:01well i didn't put this in the rundown uh they're looking for volunteers uh two thousand dollars uh to self-pleasure what um i don't we should they're doing market research yes um yeah um this is joy j-o-i which is a well-known manufacturer of um self-pleasuring devices oh wow that's that's a hefty amount to offer i

2:39:31would say yeah they hired 10 people to you know using ai companions as part of a month-long wellness study okay they came this is the best part they claim the practice could help solve male loneliness what oh no this is wired magazine for 28 days keshav had a new item on his daily to-do list this is back to the internet's promise of connecting us all

2:40:02connecting us to ourselves i guess yeah they wanted to assess what happens social aspect this is they wanted to assess what happens if erotic self-stimulation becomes an ai guided wellness ritual oh lord rule 34 34 right there in a nutshell so to speak 34 or this is this is aldous huxley this is brave new world this is this is orgy porgy this is yeah yeah um i'm gonna go go get some soma and uh we'll continue this show in a moment but first the uh the faa has announced

Gamers as air traffic controllers

2:40:39actually it's transportation secretary that uh because they can't get enough air traffic controllers sean duffy has a new plan they're gonna hire video gamers

2:40:51they've announced uh that the results of the department of transportation's unorthodox hiring campaign to use a quote supercharged hiring processor to recruit gamers sunday night since launching in april they've reached 94 percent of their hiring goal 2 000 new

2:41:11i don't know call of duty trained air traffic traffic controllers the secretary said the candidates belong to the best and brightest campaign and they're reaching the academy quicker than any class before them well it makes sense if you're a heavy duty gamer you probably have pretty good fast twitch here's the page safe skies strong careers we're hiring air traffic controllers level up your career

2:41:38the best and the brightest if it weren't for this particular operationally terrible administration i might think this might be a good idea especially if you pick if you pick people who are good at the resource management games like an animal cross you want the starcraft players i was about to say you want a starcraft pro doing this yeah exactly because they can handle 8 000 things handle happen at the same time and then the zerg are coming in but you've got to build more transformers and they're really

2:42:10yeah because the last thing i really suspect whether anybody in this administration has read ender's game but somebody did there you go don't remember ending they'll be shocked the enemy's gate is down

2:42:26down the thing i fear is someday some air traffic controller just yelling out leroy jenkins i'm going in that would be very funny yeah i was alarmed when i first heard this story but as soon as you dig into it actually isn't a terrible idea it takes two years i mean they're all going to well for two years oh yeah only a third of these people ever graduated what the critics have pointed out is you already have a one-third dropout rate because it's very stressful and then people get to the job

2:42:58and then they really drop out and so yes gamers probably have the skills but do they have the fortitude the patience uh the maturity to to do this very very very stressful job i'm guessing a lot of burnout no yeah but we'll see but who knows yeah i think it's i actually i agree with you i don't think it's a bad idea at all no it's kind of creative in a way but we'll see and that brings us to glue balls

Discovery of glue balls

2:43:23okay actually this is this is actually a big story yeah uh this is physicists in beijing with the beijing spectrometer 3 experiment it's from mars technic have discovered convincing new existence evidence of the existence of glue balls which is something uh quantum physics has predicted but never seen it's a composite particle made entirely of gluons gluons predicted see hence they're balls of gluons or

2:43:53glue balls predicted uh by quantum theory but never demonstrated now there's a pre-print uh and there's going to be there was a presentation the international conference on higher energy physics uh what's interesting is this this is the stuff that holds the universe together um it is part of the strong nuclear force it builds the strong nuclear force hence hence the gluons they glue it together the glue balls and uh we did find the higgs boson which was a particle predicted for many many decades

2:44:25finally discovered in 2012 widely touted as the final missing piece of the standard model of particle physics but it isn't really and the fact that glue balls do exist uh is further proof that uh the quantum theory is true i think this is kind of amazing it is kind of amazing and i want a band called the glue balls and the glue balls i would come to that show for sure i'm glad you all came to

2:44:56this show i bet you are too gina smith so great to see you we will certainly have you back thanks for having me i miss you and i thank you for introducing me to the vagaries of vegas and writing books this is the wonderful volume that gina and i uh collaborated on with the four i should read john's forward how did we get john to write a forward to this i begged him well that's that's probably he said no at least 10 times oh really yeah is it short and sweet let's see yes it's one page very short

2:45:29one page two yeah it says back when they were just computer industry cub reporters i knew gina and leo were going places after reading this book though i'm not so sure this book was originally my idea exclamation mark but they ran with it and now they're going to be giving high-tech writers a bad name once the average person sees how easy and simple they make computers sound leo and gina have done a killer job at putting this thing together of the tens of thousands of calls uh we took at on

2:45:59computers these are the 101 best isn't that sweet it's quite possible i wrote that for john like i we couldn't get copies from him do you kind of remember that i'm not going to say i don't know i don't remember yeah i do remember writing chapters for john's telecommunications book so i know that john was not loath to ask people to you know write stuff he gave me he didn't like to work for free either no did we not pay him we did not pay him well wow davis really was cheap yeah by nationally syndicated

2:46:36talk show host leo laporte and gina smith there we are there we go very nice gina went on to fame and fortune as abc technology reporter i stayed in the trenches at radio for another 20 years before i figured the whole thing out and got out of it and now look at you now look at me i'm a podcaster

2:46:55thank you gina great to see you thank you denise too i missed you i'm so glad to have you back i hope you had a great summer vacation denise howell and i'm glad you could join us uh you said i might be back in august did you go anywhere yeah uh my son graduated college and a girlfriend of mine's son was traveling with him so the moms came and crashed their europe trip for oh how fun oh cool yeah because it was her 60th birthday so that's what she wanted to celebrate and your son didn't mind

2:47:26your your appearance no in fact they were quite grateful because of course we picked up all the tabs while we were oh yes with them the moms will pay yes yes and then uh we do a fishing trip with my dad every summer so we went and did that yeah cherish that time that you spend with your parents i really uh yes i'm really glad that i had the time with my mom and my dad too who's still alive but it's kind of not all there uh because you know gotta you gotta get those relationships complete before

2:47:57they pass oh yeah and i tell my kids that all the time spend some time with your parents cherish the time let please give your dad a sandwich i was gonna say if you could just get him to cook i'm going out next month we're going to the podcast movement september 17th and 18th and i i called henry i said i'm coming out i please be there he said well i don't know the 19th benny is benny blanco day at uh salt hanks and it's going to be a zoo i said well i'll be there

2:48:28on the day before how about that he said okay so yeah all right we're gonna go have a sando uh at salt hanks finally i've never had one of his sandwiches never oh he's famous for what that's a crime i know yeah parental privileges i said i've had a french one french fry once no wonder he doesn't want to spend time with you he's like dad dad you don't eat my food no no it's complicated it's complicated anyway love to him and abby oh yeah absolutely abby's doing great

2:49:03she's in san francisco she did a uh she put together a poetry reading uh on friday she didn't read she just manages she writes great poetry so that was she was very nervous about that but that came off i'm sure very well and so and lisa too haven't seen her in forever yeah they were little ones gina remembers abby as a two-year-old i do she was so cute where you used to sing a little song to her do you remember the song it has to do with was it the little car i'm a little i'm a little hunk of tin nobody knows where

2:49:37i've been right we was in a running board i'm a ford a ford a ford hong kong you remember it oh that's amazing gina i remember everything with yeah vivid vivid that's awful no you know i thought man i love that no i love that i think abby probably remembers it too oh she was so cute joey great to see you and your accordion always great to see you i wish we had a time for your rendition another another time i've got a i've got a song called model leader ville jimmy model leader ville uh an ai i want to

2:50:14hear browser dancer frankly i think that private browser private browser just sing a verse for us do you remember it oh yeah totally uh do you have your accordion present of course well wait a minute folks we're gonna have a command performance of oh my private browser ladies and gentlemen i only got as far as that first line so yeah it was like i'm your private browser a browser for poor horn well and it's something for you ladies and gentlemen the great joey de villa global nerdy and of course net

2:50:52foundry everybody should be visiting net foundry because they've got great people and great software yeah and they've got there's there's one particular uh net foundry person who wants to say hi i want a great programmer andrew martinez he's forgotten more about programming than i will ever learn he wanted to say hi he's a big fan hi andrew is he vibe coding these days or is he still doing it the old-fashioned way uh i think i mean everybody's using ai assistance but i mean everybody there's a lot of

2:51:23pride in work uh there and uh i i think they're still they're they're they're still looking at code and writing code but i kind of miss it i love writing code it was just a hobby for me it was never professional uh but now it's just so easy to use agents um i i just i don't anymore but you have to check it and also you know when we're when you're working at the network level that we are um there i don't know how many examples there are of uh building zero trust overlays so yeah no that's a good point

2:51:58that's a very good point yeah this isn't a cr yeah this isn't a crud uh and if your business card says principal software engineer he actually was zed right he's one he's one of them mike uh i mean z zed is a whole bunch of it's eugene it's michael there's a whole bunch of folks uh but yeah but uh but i promised andrew i would say hi well hi andrew uh you have my deepest respect because uh core to zed was pretty amazing is is pretty amazing still a great open source project and you can find it at

Club TWIT and wrap up

2:52:34net foundry thank you everybody for joining us we do twit sundays 2 to 5 p.m pacific 5 to 8 eastern that's 2100 utc you can watch us as we do it uh especially if you're a club twit member that's the that's the best way to get the behind the velvet rope access to everything we do it helps us out greatly 10 bucks a month gets you ad-free versions of all the shows you get chapter markers in the shows you get access to the club twit discord where there may or may not be um accordion music day and night

2:53:08uh you also get the special programming we do in the club twit discord like our ai user group which is now twice a month because there's so much to talk about our uh photography a show with chris marquardt let's see what we got coming up uh micah's crafting corner is wednesday that's always fun micah last i saw was doing origami but he's always doing different crafts our uh photo assignment this month is rugged with chris marquardt that's coming up stacy's book club oh i gotta get reading slow gods

2:53:39it's coming up in about a week friday august 21st clear north's slow gods we'll be back with the ar user group micah's media club actually we've already done the vote on that one and uh micah's media club this week is going to do the or this month is going to do the top animated episodes futuramas jurassic bark uh rick and morty total rickle and the simpsons marge versus the monorail i love monorail monorail it is so much fun so that was the winner uh the vote concluded a couple of weeks ago so we'll be

2:54:12talking about that micah's media corner this is why you want to be in the club smart people it's fun and it supports everything we do here at twitter and it's vital to our continued existence to be honest twitter tv club twitter if you're not a member even if you're not a member you can still watch us do the show live as i mentioned youtube twitch x facebook linkedin kick after the fact on demand versions of the show at our website twit.tv we do audio and video you can download it for free and watch it at your leisure there is a youtube channel uh youtube.com twit obviously actually all the shows have

2:54:46dedicated channels you can go there and watch the show great way to you know share little clips with friends and family if you want to it helps us if you do that and it's a great way to say hey did you see this and of course you can subscribe probably that's the best way to do it and your favorite podcast player subscribe and you'll get it automatically for free whenever uh whenever we're done you can download it and start listening at your pleasure i used to always say uh download it first thing monday morning for your monday morning commute but nowadays many people commute upstairs it's

2:55:16not such a long commute it's a long show so uh save it for that i don't know uh that ferry ride or something hey thanks for listening thanks for watching thanks to our wonderful panel gina denise and joey we'll see you all next time we'll see you all soon thanks so much as i've said for 21 years now gina another twit is in the can this is amazing

2:55:42doing the twit all right doing the twit baby doing the twit all right